Basically, a site has to offer something to both women and men to do better than OKC. That proposal just puts a minor speed bump in front of men. As a group, men have few compunctions about abusing sites in order to get what they want. Multiple accounts to spam women is not a significant obstacle.
And now you have to work harder to manage that, reducing the probability that you'll be doing it.
Basically, your approach is the functional equivalent of DRM. With all the problems that go with that.
But you know what? It doesn't take all that many before women have experiences not so different from that of OKC.
Then I stopped to think about it and understood why.
Happy? Or would you prefer #NotAllMen?
"I, personally, discovered..."
The entire seduction and pickup community is based on the idea that women say they want a guy who's nice and plays by the rules but that that isn't what they respond to. They respond to assholes, bad-boys and dominant men. Obviously not every woman, but there are plenty of independent scientific studies to support this theory.
In any case, there's a big difference between 'spammer' and 'bad-boy' as well as a big difference between demonstrating the success of a strategy and demonstrating it's prevalence.
Edit: There may be some good studies demonstrating causation but I am not familiar with them.
However, when the statements are of the general form about the group as a whole, I think it is a perfectly appropriate response. If you say "All men are misogynists" saying "no we aren't" is perfectly valid, so is taking offense to the statement.
Now if you have evidence that your assertion applies to the majority of men on dating sites, feel free to post it. Then at least your stereotype will be an evidence backed one.