News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mac App Store: The Subtle Exodus by Tloewald on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @01:22PM (#8454531)
The problem with the App Store isn't that Apple is making too much money from developers (they're not making more money than anyone else who retails products for you). The problem is that the App Store doesn't support stuff developers need, like upgrades, migration from previous licensing schemes, free trials (vs. in-app purchases of functionality). This was very much a Steve-ism (let's keep things simple for customers) but they need to treat developers as customers too.
Re:Mac App Store: The Subtle Exodus by byEngineer on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @01:30PM (#8454580)
I like the idea of making it easy on customers. I'd rather go through additional pain as a business/developer and make more money (better product) than have an ecosystem that is unfriendly for paying customer but nice for geeks like me. What I love as a consumer in my iPhone (compared to Android, etc.) is no upgrades -- annoying like hell. No messages about license changes (thanks God!).

Why you guys insist on making sure that your software is annoying to people who use it?! I don't get it. Where is Steve?!

Re:Mac App Store: The Subtle Exodus by Tloewald on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @03:51PM (#8455351)
Is it easier for customers to go to a website to download a demo version? This is happening now with MAS.

Or to use in-app purchases to unlock features? (I can get apps with subscriptions ffs, but not get upgrade pricing or free demos with a single activation fee that is diffrentiated from in-app purchases.)

Is it easier for customers to pay full price for a new version instead of getting upgrade pricing? Similarly is it better to force long-term customers to pay full price if you migrate to the app store?

Is it easier for customers to have to install betas from the developer in order to deploy a hot-fix that's stuck in the approval pipeline?

Now, I realize that in a perfect world developers would maintain their software for existing customers and sell new features as in-app purchases, but this is the real world, and sometimes you want to do major changes and not worry about how to shoehorn it into the MAS policy. And, of course, Apple doesn't have to eat its own dogfood here.

Re:Mac App Store: The Subtle Exodus by benaiah on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @01:40PM (#8454641)
Everything you mention is either A: still part of the MAS or B: needed by both developers and consumers.

> What I love as a consumer in my iPhone (compared to Android, etc.) is no upgrades -- annoying like hell. WTF? iPhone and Android have almost exactly the same upgrade policy. Both automatically update apps, and have done for ages. The only app store in the discussion that does ask you about updates by default is the MAS.

> No messages about license changes Nobody mentioned this. Someone did mention "migration from previous licensing schemes", but that's about not making people pay twice for the same app, not bugging people about license changes. Besides, you do get something similar on iOS - it bugs you, as it should, whenever an app wants new permissions.

The MAS may be simpler for consumers than what we want, but it's not easier. It's a huge PITA for everyone who has to use it in any way outside of the single most obvious manner. These aren't even edge cases, these are just cases outside of the default.

Re:Mac App Store: The Subtle Exodus by milen on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @01:37PM (#8454620)
The whole point is that nothing will change, as far as the consumer experience is concerned. You won't get bothered about upgrades or anything like this. All that would happen is you might see an "Upgrade" button in your list of apps you purchased. That's it.

Note that while the notion of paying once and getting infinite updates forever is quite nice, it's not rooted in reality. Either the app you're using will get abandoned or you will have to pay up at some point in the future, somehow - ads, IAP, etc.

Re:Mac App Store: The Subtle Exodus by tormeh on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @01:49PM (#8454694)
Or the developer makes a sequel app, and you have to pay again to get the new one.
Re:Mac App Store: The Subtle Exodus by byEngineer on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @02:16PM (#8454837)
I like that concept. I paid to go from MS DOS 3.5 to MS DOS 5.0. Have no problem doing the same with your app bro!
Re:Mac App Store: The Subtle Exodus by mgkimsal on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @01:52PM (#8454702)
I guess I never understood why a 'free trial' was not 'simple' but 'in-app purchases' is 'simple'. Many of the apps I look at get bad reviews because the app only provides a trial aspect anyway - 'full' functionality is unlocked as 'in app purchase'. And people down vote for that (feeling they're being misled).
Re:Mac App Store: The Subtle Exodus by smackfu on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @02:55PM (#8455059)
The key moment was when they allowed in-app purchases for free apps in October 2009, after introducing IAP in March 2009. If they had held that line, the app store would be a much different place.
Re:Mac App Store: The Subtle Exodus by 0x0 on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @02:26PM (#8454903)
I wonder if a simple fix would be to add a button next to the existing "free"-labeled download button. The new button is labeled with a price and would purchase the in-app "pro features" in addition to starting the download.
Re:Mac App Store: The Subtle Exodus by vitd on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @02:37PM (#8454966)
They already have something like this. They list the top 5 in-app purchases for an app right on its page. For example, for “Mini Motor Racing” (never played it, but it’s highlighted today), it shows that you can buy “30,000 career cash” for $0.99, or “Unlock all purchasable cars” for $2.99. Sounds like problem solved to me!
Re:Mac App Store: The Subtle Exodus by wwweston on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @01:37PM (#8454621)
Right, the money isn't a problem, it's just something of a cause -- because they're doing so well at the moment, they don't have incentives to change and it's very easy to take the money they are making as a signal that they're doing things right.

Then add that to a pretty magisterial culture...