Re:Losing 58.3 Lbs for Science
by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @11:16AM
(#8453777)
To test the truth, try the converse. If you eat more, will you gain weight? Most of us would agree this is an obvious truism.
Or take the limit. If you eat nothing, will you lose weight? Obviously you will.
The question exists because folks want to eat as much as they can, and also lose weight. Give in to thermodynamics, eat very little, and lose weight as quickly as you like. That's chemistry and physics right there.
Re:Losing 58.3 Lbs for Science
by crazygringo on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @01:10PM
(#8454451)
Again, nope. If you're ~50 lbs overweight, and then cut out starches and sugars, replacing them with protein and fat, but increase your overall calorie intake slightly, there's still a good chance you will lose weight.
So, not an obvious truism, but actually incorrect.
Re:Losing 58.3 Lbs for Science
by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday October 14, 2014 @02:30PM
(#8454927)
What was that in response to? Did you post to the wrong comment? I'm confused.
And that's the point -- calories burned is not a constant. It changes a great deal, and it's very common for the body to respond to less calories in, by burning less calories.