News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by cperciva on Saturday September 26, 2009 @01:40AM (#845112)
Knowing who wrote a comment often provides very useful context (especially when there is back-and-forth discussion going on).
Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by plinkplonk on Saturday September 26, 2009 @01:46AM (#845123)
pvg said -> "It would be a little difficult to have an exchange with someone if you can't tell who is who."

cperciva said "Knowing who wrote a comment often provides very useful context"

You are both completely right. My suggestion doesn't make sense.

It was just a "spur of the moment" suggestion to provoke thought (de Bono's PO mental operator). I dind't think it through at all.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by Prolitheus on Saturday September 26, 2009 @01:56AM (#845137)
You could give everyone a unique identifier per thread.
Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by Radix on Saturday September 26, 2009 @03:05AM (#845203)
That would only solve one of the problems. Some of the users here are skilled enough that the average user doesn't know enough to keep up a disagreement. It's easier if the user names stay.

For instance, the ggp is a security professional. I give more credence to his opinions than others.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by Prolitheus on Saturday September 26, 2009 @03:28AM (#845227)
It was only intended to solve one of the problems, as the other 'problem' is exactly what removing the names would seek to address: a person's authority/history influencing the weight of their comments within a thread. It'd really benefit people who've earned a negative following, but I don't see such a mob mentality on here as opposed to certain aggregators in which biases become apparent in just a few threads.
Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by camccann on Saturday September 26, 2009 @10:07AM (#845462)
Yes, but sometimes a person's authority is actually relevant. Consider this short exchange from the other day: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=841887

On the other hand, when somebody who is deeply respected (be it pg, or any prolific high-karma commenter) posts on something where they have no particular expertise the comment shouldn't get special consideration due to the author.

I can't think of a way to reconcile these, and there's enough people who post here that are actual authorities in relevant areas that I wouldn't want to give up the first. Being able to know that, say, a comment about security was written by tptacek matters more to me than "oh look, pg made a two-word post that got 9001 points".