News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by jrockway on Saturday September 26, 2009 @12:31AM (#844988)
I can still see the score on the "edit" page, which means I can still edit my post to whine about being downmodded. Since nobody knows the degree that I am being downmodded to (or corrected to), people might upvote more than they should.

(I have also noticed that people don't stop upmodding even if the score is visible. I got 80 points yesterday on a one-line comment poking fun at Joel Spolsky. WTF?)

Just like when there is the delayed "reply" link that isn't showing, you can still reply to a comment by clicking the "link" link.

Edit: why is this being downmodded?

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by pg on Saturday September 26, 2009 @12:39AM (#845001)
Fixed.

I didn't see the comment you mention, but that is exactly the sort of thing I meant about voting starting to have a mob feel.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by jrockway on Saturday September 26, 2009 @12:50AM (#845023)
It was this one: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=840748

Although I don't have any data, I think that if the same comment was posted today, it would end up with more points. If I see a comment with 80 upvotes, I usually let it stay there rather than bumping it to 81.

One other comment; I find it hard to navigate my "threads" page now. I used to focus on highly-voted comments to improve and reply to; now that I don't know what other people like, I have nothing to go on.

I guess spending less time on HN might not be a bad thing, however :)

Edit: one more thing. I still have a reflex-like urge to click the upvote button when the author name says "pg". With no number, it is even harder to suppress the urge.

So far I have managed, but I can't guarantee that I won't change my mind :)

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by netsp on Saturday September 26, 2009 @01:22AM (#845085)
I was thinking something similar when I saw this change. I know I am affected by by the comments score when I vote, but I think it's more of a moderating effect. I might vote down a smart ass one line remark if it has lots of points, or vote up something that is so-so if it's been voted down.

Interesting to experiment.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by peoplerock on Saturday September 26, 2009 @03:47AM (#845238)
I think it would be very informative to collect data on whether or not that sort of mob effect gets diminished by removing display of the comment-votes: will it keep "cute" one-line jabs from soaring to top of page?

PS: please don't ask me how to quantify such data :)