News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by seanmcdirmid on Monday October 13, 2014 @09:52AM (#8448694)
Anyone who lives in China knows it's "complicated," but journalists just report, they don't editorialize. The quote thing is used more often by Chinese reporters to talk about the "president" of Taiwan, which is obviously sensitive for them. They might also say the leader of Taiwan, but this is unprofessional. Incidentally, the ROC government has more congruity with pre 1949 China than the PRC one.

As for DPRK, reporters say that, and they refer to Kim Jong Un as "dear leader" since that is what the North Koreans use, not because he is particularly dear.

Even when Stalin was in charge, communism was more of a name than a stringent mantle to uphold. The communist party might not be very communist, the Nazi's weren't very socialist. Names are just that.

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by vidarh on Monday October 13, 2014 @11:19AM (#8449025)
> but journalists just report, they don't editorialize.

I don't know what media you pay attention to, but I don't know of a single media source that don't editorialise.

> and they refer to Kim Jong Un as "dear leader" since that is what the North Koreans use

When Western media refers to "dear leader" it is almost always ironic, as a standing joke about how ridiculous over the top DPRK propaganda is, not because "that is what the North Koreans use". It is very often interjected in contexts where there is no reason to include it other than because it sounds ridiculous to their audience.

> The communist party might not be very communist, the Nazi's weren't very socialist. Names are just that.

Names are not just that when they are intentionally used to colour public perception. It is perfectly valid to question why journalists word things the way they do.

If the NYT often refers to "friendly" governments the same way - by including a reference to the governing party - then it's probably just a stylistic choice. If they single out certain nations/parties, then that's a different matter.

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by seanmcdirmid on Monday October 13, 2014 @02:16PM (#8449829)
But NYT doesn't differ with Xinhua in this case. It is very hard to call that significant bias.
Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by vidarh on Monday October 13, 2014 @03:15PM (#8450076)
I don't see how that is relevant.

The same use of language can have wildly different implications for different target demographics, and even different meanings, and so the effect of emphasising a certain aspect can be neutral or positive in one context, and negative in another.

"Dear leader" from before is a perfect example of that, which is respectful in one context and outright mocking in other. If you use it in a mocking way, but refer to all other leaders in a neutral way, it's not a good defence that North Korean media uses the same language.

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by seanmcdirmid on Monday October 13, 2014 @08:21PM (#8451320)
If dear leader is referred to as "supreme leader" (the official title of the DPRK head of state), then you refer to them as supreme leader or dear leader or whatever title they want to use. You just really don't have a choice in the matter as a journalist, whatever the result is.

If the communist party wants to be called the communist party even though they don't really hold up to the ideals of communism, then ditto. You don't have the right as a journalist to make up titles for world leaders or organizations that you believe would be less biased or less mocking, or whatever, you just report the news.