News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by chrisBob on Monday October 13, 2014 @08:05AM (#8448356)
>I have lived in China.

> USA is very rich but also terribly poor. Living in the USA you see poorer people than anywhere else in a western society. And poverty is rising enormously.

This is a very interesting perspective; did you ever travel to rural parts of China? I have never been to china, but my Chinese lab mate says that the best translation for Chinese outside of the cities is "peasant" not farmer. One good example of the way these people are treated is the lack of public education for people in these areas. In the US some schools are much better than others, but every child is guaranteed a public education, and has the opportunity to train for a reasonable job.

Similarly I have friends from Iraq and Nepal who are happy here. Pretty much everyone in the US has heat, running water, a modern dwelling... I know very little about Europe and other western societies though, so perhaps it is much worse here than in some places.

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by xiaq on Monday October 13, 2014 @10:46AM (#8448895)
> I have never been to china, but my Chinese lab mate says that the best translation for Chinese outside of the cities is "peasant" not farmer. One good example of the way these people are treated is the lack of public education for people in these areas.

I live in China, and I wonder which rural areas you are talking about. From my knowledge, primary and secondary school (known as 9-year compulsory education) attendance is virtually 100% everywhere with two notable exceptions, namely extremely mountainous areas and the autonomous regions. In extremely mountainous areas transportation is almost impossible and schools tend to be underfunded; the problem with autonomous regions is beyond my knowledge.

To back my claim with statistics, a report from the Ministry of Education (http://www.moe.edu.cn/publicfiles/business/htmlfiles/moe/moe..., the report is in Chinese) estimated the net primary school enrollment ratio at 99.71%. A more dated UNESCO report from 2000 (http://www.unesco.org/education/wef/countryreports/china/rap...) estimated the net primary school enrollment ratio at 98.5% in the year 1998.

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by adventured on Monday October 13, 2014 @11:28AM (#8449070)
Rural China is basically one of the three poorest places on Earth, with the average person earning $2 or $3 per day. It's comparable to the poorest locations in India and Africa.

I'm not sure how that's even remotely a valid comparison or point of reference to the standard for American poor.

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by seanmcdirmid on Monday October 13, 2014 @08:22PM (#8451323)
It is not the poorest place on earth, Africa is much poorer. Even a poor farmer in Guizhou does much better than say many parts of India or Africa. Incidentally, China is a middle income country, and you can't really compare it to lower income countries anymore (even that poor farmer in Guizhou is going to have a TV and is not going to steal highway signs to make cookware as happens in Africa leading to serating just to keep them around).

Just draw a thick line between lower and middle income countries (e.g. India is upper lower income).

Incidentally, Guizhou, Yunnan, Jiangxi, Sichuan, etc... are fairly mountainous and autonomous (based on ethnicity), so education is a problem as xiaq said. But education in China up to the 9th grade is north of 95%, most people aren't illiterate and can at least use their smart phones (which even poor farmers have now) for texting their friends.

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by xiaq on Monday October 13, 2014 @12:39PM (#8449406)
Yes it's very poor, but we're talking about education here. Primary and secondary education is free except for a yearly contribution that is typically 100 to 200 Yuan (16 to 32 dollars), which even the poorest family can afford. I heard that even the contribution has been cut in recent years, but I cannot verify that.
Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by rsynnott on Monday October 13, 2014 @08:25AM (#8448401)
> This is a very interesting perspective; did you ever travel to rural parts of China?

China isn't what would normally be considered a western society; I assume they were talking about the developed world.

Much of the developed world does have substantially better social safety nets that the US, and lower rates of income inequality, though probably not due to the distribution of ownership of farmland.

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by zo1 on Monday October 13, 2014 @08:44AM (#8448459)
"Much of the developed world does have substantially better social safety nets that the US, and lower rates of income inequality"

Can you point me to your sources on this, I'm quite curious?

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by dragontamer on Monday October 13, 2014 @09:58AM (#8448717)
The better social safety nets are damn obvious. Much of Europe (including UK) has free education up to College-level, truly universal healthcare (State-Sponsored for all citizens).

As for income inequality, the statistics are pretty telling.

http://money.cnn.com/2011/11/08/news/economy/global_income_i...

But it is the goal of liberalism to have strong social safety nets and equalize pay to all. The US has a different culture with different values... tending towards the "conservative" and with great trust in market forces.

"Obamacare" is seen as Socialism and half the population seems to hate it. But Obamacare only establishes rules for the free market to operate under... standardizing health care plans across insurance companies. There is no state-sponsored health care from the law, and yet people are still worried about socialism.

Obamacare is closer to Credit Card reform, in that it forced all credit card companies in the US to standardize upon the "Annual Percentage Rate" / APR so that everyone can comparison shop across credit cards. With Obamacare, all insurance companies have to offer similar plans (bronze, silver, gold, platinum), and they must cover certain provisions (contraceptives make the controversy here). So now when you see a "Bronze" plan from say... Aetna Health Insurance, you know it is similar to "Bronze" plans from Kaiser Permanente.

As far as the "Socialism" goes... US has had Medicare / Medicaid for nearly 80 years now. The "socialist" part of our health care system has existed for a very long time, but no Republican seems to want to attack it.

But inside the US, any new laws upon the market is seen as a "Market Distortion" and is criticized as "Socialism". Because most American's don't even know the meaning of that word. The absurdity in the "Net Neutrality" argument is more proof of the free market sheeple ignoring important issues and placing their trust in the free market instead.

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by adventured on Monday October 13, 2014 @11:36AM (#8449104)
What does a free education get you in most of Europe exactly, when most of Europe is poor beyond what the average American can even imagine?

People like to pretend Europe is only Germany, Britain, France, Norway etc.

Moldova, Czech, Belarus, Romania, Ukraine, Slovakia, Latvia, Poland, Lithuania, Russia, Hungary, Bulgaria and so on. These are countries that are dramatically poorer than the US. What does the amazing free education there get you? A $300 or $400 per month minimum wage.

An amazing social safety net where you're among the poorest 50% on earth? I don't get how that's something to celebrate.

I've known plenty of poor people, having grown up in dirt poor Appalachia, and growing up poor myself. I've never known a single truly poor person that couldn't get free healthcare from the government.

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by sanoli on Monday October 13, 2014 @11:35AM (#8449099)
> Because most American's don't even know the meaning of that word.

I'll have to agree with you on this one. To me it always sounds for a split second that whoever compares it with socialism is joking, and then I'm reminded that Americans say this in all seriousness. I wonder, what's the Republican and Tea Party members views on public education? Are they against it? 100% free market education? (serious question)

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by zo1 on Monday October 13, 2014 @04:12PM (#8450365)
Well, I'm an anarcho-capitalist. And I advocate no government intervention, in everything.

When I use the term "socalism" or "socialist" while discussing a political topic, it doesn't mean I'm comparing it to, or saying it is Socialism. To me, like I would assume most other anarcho-capitalists and libertarians, socialism isn't a binary. It's a grey-scale towards socialism. So, while most would not say that public schooling or a social safety-net are "socialist" or meaning we have "Socialism", the anarcho-capitalists and libertarians would just be implying that this is one of the many things on the way to socialism.

Perhaps we're wrong, and these extras and government-projects, etc won't lead to a full socialist form of government. But every single time one of those things is enacted, it's a step in the direction of a less free society. A step in less voluntary and peaceful ways of solving problems. We say peaceful and voluntary because by our definition, government is neither of those (but that's a whole long discussion just by itself).

*edit: missing word.

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by dragontamer on Monday October 13, 2014 @08:30PM (#8451339)
And the problem is that Socialists use the word "Socialist" because they believe the Free Market leads to centralized power and monopolists enforcing their viewpoint of the world upon everyone else.

I've talked to _real_ socialists, and I do believe myself to be ultimately a free market capitalist kind of guy... at least by default.

But unfortunately, the world isn't a simple place, and there are simple mathematical proofs in Game Theory that prove pure liassez-faire capitalism to be wrong. The free market fails in cases as simple as "The Stag Hunt", so it is ultimately the point of a capitalist government to intervene in any of the documented cases where the Free Market fails to work.

No anarcho-capitalist has ever given me a clear answer on how Cell Phones would work today if it weren't for government regulation enforcing the 2.4GHz spectrum for Wi-Fi, and also enforcing the licensing of spectrum. I like the fact that it is illegal to disturb other people's cell phones.

The Licensing of Spectrum is neither socialist, nor pure anarcho-capitalist. It is a mechanism Americans invented to avoid a market-failure cornercase. Without licensing of spectrum, competitors would create cell phones that disturbed cell phones from other companies. Without government intervention, it is impossible to create property-rights and "ownership of spectrum" that leads to today's cell phones.

And all anarcho-capitalists I know of also understand that a consistent viewpoint of "property rights" need to exist for any form of captialism to work. If you're like other anarcho-capitalists I've talked to, you'll go on about Dispute resolution organization and how they're different from judges.

The main problem is that if two Dispute resolution organization have different viewpoints on property rights (ie: one likes the concept of licensed spectrum and another one doesn't), then property rights ultimately fail to exist at all, and then capitalism breaks down entirely.

The socialist approach to solving the problem is to have the Government own all cell phone companies. This is _very_ distinct from the American solution, where the Federal Government created the concept of "spectrum" that different companies can then buy and sell to each other.

So seeing the world as "Socialist vs Anarcho-capitalist" is extremely naiive, and absolutely frustrating to those who like to discuss policy matters. The world is not binary, there are many different solutions to a single problem. Calling everything you disagree with as "socialism" simplifies arguments into a "them vs us" situation and stigmatizes debate.

Honest, learn to call _real_ socialist things as socialist. Not every single government intervention is a socialist plot.

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by gretful on Monday October 13, 2014 @10:50AM (#8448912)
Obamacare is closer to car-insurance, with the caveat that even if you don't want a car you still have to buy the insurance. THAT is what has most of the nay-sayers agitated.

Medicare/Medicaid are, like the student loan programs with college tuition, at least partially responsible for driving up the costs of healthcare in the US.

We've backed ourselves into a very difficult corner, and getting out of it isn't going to be easy, and it won't be popular.

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by cpwright on Monday October 13, 2014 @11:31AM (#8449084)
Car insurance doesn't protect you, it protects the other drivers on the road. You can decide to risk it, and if your brand new car is totaled, its on you [assuming you paid cash, if you finance it any lender will also make you get collision and comprehensive]. What you can't decide to do is forgo liability insurance so that if you hit someone else's car they have to extract the payment from you rather than from a well-capitalized insurance company.

Of course this is all state regulated (and this is US-centric, but so is Obamacare), so it can work differently in different places.

Health insurance nominally protects you, though some make the argument that it protects society as a whole from any individual burdening the system.

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by gretful on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @03:41PM (#8461184)
Put Drs/Hospitals/HealthCare in place of the other car, and your body in place of your car. The analogy works very well. ACA is acting as the bank in the car insurance analogy, demanding that you HAVE to have bumper-to-bumper collision insurance.

In the car insurance case you can forgo the car and thereby forgo purchasing car insurance, but with the ACA you can't forgo health insurance.

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by dragontamer on Monday October 13, 2014 @11:27AM (#8449067)

     Obamacare is closer to car-insurance, with the caveat
     that even if you don't want a car you still have to buy 
     the insurance. THAT is what has most of the nay-sayers 
     agitated.
I must be listening to different nay-sayers than you.

http://www.foxnews.com/on-air/oreilly/2014/07/24/bill-oreill...

Bill O'Reilly, who is frankly a good conservative voice, clearly thinks that "Obamacare is Socialism"... that it is about income redistribution.

Which tells us a few things: Bill O'Reilly hasn't read Obamacare, and he also doesn't understand what "Socialism" means. Otherwise, he'd be attacking Medicaid.

And Bill O'Reilly is actually an overall intelligent guy. I do enjoy listening to him a lot of the time. His opinion and views are generally very reflective of conservatives. So when Bill O'Reilly gets it wrong, it reflects poorly upon conservatives as a whole.

-------------

Without getting into the Obamacare debate, you have to admit that a fairly large portion of the conservative crowd doesn't even understand what "Socialism" is. That's what I'm trying to say.

Obamacare is a massive example. The individual mandate has absolutely nothing to do with socialism or income redistribution, but is instead a provision to eradicate "pre-existing conditions" clauses in insurance companies.

Socialism is... like the US Postal Office. The Government ownership of a service that the Free Market could take over. (ie: FedEx / UPS)

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by gretful on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @03:39PM (#8461167)
Nothing? So the fact that young (presumably healthy) people HAVE to buy insurance to make ACA a success means nothing. It's pretty clear that the mandate IS Socialism.
Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by dragontamer on Thursday October 16, 2014 @10:58AM (#8465233)
No, that has absolutely nothing to do with Socialism.

    Socialism is a social and economic system characterised
    by social ownership of the means of production and
    co-operative management of the economy, as well as a
    political theory and movement that aims at the
    establishment of such a system.
If you don't like it, then say that you don't like it. But calling it "socialism" is absolute ignorance. It only demonstrates the fact that you don't know what Socialism is.

Socialism: Medicaid, Postal Office. When the government owns and manages a core service, that is Socialism.

Individual Mandate: Its a regulation, legally its a tax. The government is forcing you to do something, like drive under 65mph or making leaded gasoline illegal to buy. Or making it illegal for you to smoke in certain areas.

In fact, when I hear people call the Individual Mandate "socialist", it tells me two things: 1. You don't know the meaning of socialism 2. You probably don't understand the Individual Mandate.

Maybe you don't like the Individual mandate. That is fine. I don't really like it either and preferred Mitt Romney's solution. It probably was possible to fix the Health Care system without resorting to the Individual Mandate... but to call it "socialism" is wrong.

How about you figure out how to criticize policy without resorting to words you don't even understand.

-----------------

Let me help you. I criticize the individual mandate as overhanded, excessive, burdensome regulation, difficult to enforce. Empowering to the IRS. An unnecessary tax on citizens. An abuse of the Commerce Clause.

You know, facts, real reasons why the Individual Mandate sucks. But to call it "socialism" is pure ignorance.

Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by dragontamer on Monday October 13, 2014 @09:53AM (#8448699)

    Much of the developed world
Hardly relevant when we're comparing the USA to China however.
Re:Once a Symbol of Power, Farming Now an Economic Drag in C... by rsynnott on Monday October 13, 2014 @10:17AM (#8448782)
The original comment said that the US has big poverty problems compared to other western countries, not compared to China.