Re:Alfred Anaya Put Secret Compartments in Cars. The DEA Put...
by baddox on Sunday October 12, 2014 @04:11AM
(#8444740)
> I said that making decisions at the individual level about which laws are rational and breaking the irrational ones is not feasible.
What do you mean by "feasible"? I am certainly capable of deciding which laws I think are rational and choosing which laws to obey.
> Civil disobedience is almost never undertaken at the individual level, and more specifically it is never successful at the individual level. It is an exercise undertaken by a society.
You seem to be conflating civil disobedience with organized protest or resistance. Civil disobedience is just a deliberate refusal to obey a rule one believes to be a bad rule. It doesn't have to be organized.
You seem to have a disdain for all individual discretion about rules and laws. I disagree, and strongly. Only individuals act, and I think only individuals have the ability and responsibility to choose how to act.
Civil disobedience is almost never undertaken at the individual level, and more specifically it is never successful at the individual level. It is an exercise undertaken by a society. Society making judgements about the rationality of laws and then using civil and legislative means to affect change on the laws themselves is healthy and valid.
By contrast, making these judgements at the individual level opens up a whole world of danger, because our individual feelings on what is and is not rational vary as widely as our viewpoints on everything else.