Re:The Internet of Someone Else’s Things
by chubot on Saturday October 11, 2014 @02:46PM
(#8443052)
This question doesn't make sense -- Paxos and the blockchain solve different problems. You were probably misled by people talking about how the blockchain solves distributed consensus. That's a decent analogy but not a precise statement about computer science.
There are several differences, but the main one is that with Paxos all the members are trusted, and have to be under a single administrative domain. With the blockchain, the whole point is to come to consensus without trust in a central authority.
Other differences:
- Paxos (Chubby, etcd) and related algorithms (Zab/Zookeeper) are used with a small, fixed membership -- i.e. 3 to 7 servers. Everybody else is a client. In contrast, the blockchain is for a huge, frequently changing membership.
- Paxos is expensive and is used within a single data center with LAN latency. The blockchain is used in the exact opposite situation: on the Internet with large latencies and large variance in latency.
There are several differences, but the main one is that with Paxos all the members are trusted, and have to be under a single administrative domain. With the blockchain, the whole point is to come to consensus without trust in a central authority.
Other differences:
- Paxos (Chubby, etcd) and related algorithms (Zab/Zookeeper) are used with a small, fixed membership -- i.e. 3 to 7 servers. Everybody else is a client. In contrast, the blockchain is for a huge, frequently changing membership.
- Paxos is expensive and is used within a single data center with LAN latency. The blockchain is used in the exact opposite situation: on the Internet with large latencies and large variance in latency.