News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What makes for a stable marriage? by themartorana on Saturday October 11, 2014 @11:07AM (#8442332)
> there's not really such a thing as a bad marriage so much as selfish participants

This is absurd. It's constructed of a series of suppositions, only a few of which I'll address.

First is that people are static. This simply isn't true. We all know that we all change - not just in age, wisdom, and so on, but in tastes, politics, religious dedication, and the lines we draw between wrong and right, just to name a few.

In just these ways, people can grow apart. The distance between these changes can, in fact, cause "irreconcilable differences."

Sometimes these changes are brought about by dramatic stress events, from the death of a child to major swings in financial stability. The way in which these events change the unwilling participants can again lead to incompatibility where once there was compatibility.

But worst is the idea that if people just "work on it" they can overcome anything. Sometimes overcoming growing apart - be it over time or rather quickly - is best done by removing yourself from a situation that is no longer positive, and has little ability to become positive again.

This is where I find religion quite often inserts itself negatively. While I agree with a poster above that regular attendance at religious gatherings does often help a couple share a support network, share common beliefs and similar circles of friends, etc., religion often tells you only divorce or failed marriage is an abomination, and a personal failure requiring lifetime penance. It then follows by labeling that person as an outcast, no longer worthy of the community they had once belonged to.

These are just a few reasons (not to mention physical/substance abuse, and so on) that marriages can fail without it being personal failure. Your assertion does nothing but pile on further stigma to those who have gone through divorce. No one wants their marriage to fail, but when it does, it isn't always personal failure that requires additional shaming from outsiders.

Re:What makes for a stable marriage? by Xcelerate on Saturday October 11, 2014 @11:43AM (#8442401)
> series of suppositions ... First is that people are static.

I don't know of anyone who believes people are static. You even say yourself in the next sentence "We all know that we all change". No one (at least that I'm aware of) goes into marriage expecting the person they marry to stay the same over time. Another HN poster (can't remember who) put it beautifully once: marriage is an agreement to learn to love the person that each of you become over time.

A marriage is a promise, a vow, to commit to this. Now, I could certainly see a situation where two people tell each other at the altar "I promise to love and support you always, well... unless we change too much". However, both people should be aware of these terms! You can't make an agreement that you will always, unconditionally support the other person, and then back out of it later because you changed your mind. If both people are in agreement that they might change and get divorced later before the marriage begins, then fine with me. It's not that different than dating with some legal benefits. But if one person thinks they're going into something permanent, and the other person has doubts about it, then that is really not fair to the first person, and I would argue it's essentially evil to be that dishonest to someone.

> further stigma to those who have gone through divorce

There is a stigma, but it's not on divorce; it's on someone who goes back on their word. What are my terms for divorce? If there is abuse or cheating. Those are my only conditions. And before I marry anyone, I will make it very clear that these are the only conditions in which I will abandon them, and if they don't like those terms they can marry someone else. The stigma associated with the vast majority of divorces is that one (or two) people were unable to keep a promise. I don't want to be associated with these kinds of people. My life is simpler and happier if I associate with people who will keep their word at any cost. Maybe your experience is different.

Re:What makes for a stable marriage? by jjoonathan on Saturday October 11, 2014 @12:09PM (#8442481)
> marriage is an agreement to learn to love the person that each of you become over time

The supposition that it is always possible to learn to love the other person is as ridiculous as the supposition that people are static.

> If both people are in agreement that they might change and get divorced later before the marriage begins, then fine with me.

Everyone who gets married knows that the possibility of divorce exists and roughly what divorce proceedings entail. How does making these details explicit as opposed to implicit help anyone?

> There is a stigma, but it's not on divorce; it's on someone who goes back on their word.

I would wager that very few people are as hot-to-trot as you are on the notion of honor in contract literalism.

> My life is simpler, more enjoyable, and happier if I associate with people who will keep their word at any cost. Maybe your experience is different.

It is. Honesty is valuable, but by my way of reckoning there is little honesty in the practice of enshrining outdated guesses about the future. A promise made without implicit limits is a lie.

Re:What makes for a stable marriage? by Xcelerate on Saturday October 11, 2014 @12:46PM (#8442600)
> The supposition that it is always possible to learn to love the other person is as ridiculous as the supposition that people are static.

No it's not. What do you support that statement with?

> Everyone who gets married knows that the possibility of divorce exists and roughly what divorce proceedings entail.

> I would wager that very few people are as hot-to-trot as you are on the notion of honor in contract literalism

I've found that people's life experiences significantly shape their views on things. Friends of mine that come from family backgrounds with a lot of divorce have the same view that you do. I call it the "realist" view. The idea of a permanent happy relationship is viewed with pessimism, as an "unrealistic fairy tale", because they've either never seen such a thing or experienced it themselves.

On the other hand, I come from a family background with multiple, near-perfect half-century or longer marriages. Out of my entire extended family, only one person has been divorced. And I wonder -- the divorce rate is so much lower in my family (30 or so people) than the rest of society -- why is this? And I think it's the "hot-to-trot notion of contract literalism" that you so summarily dismiss.

There's something fascinating that I've begun to realize in the last few years, and it's that people assume everyone else is more similar to them (or people they grew up with) than is actually the case. Cheaters assume everyone else would secretly cheat, just like them, given a good enough opportunity or motive. Liars assume everyone else does the same. They find it hard to believe that people actually do exist that don't view the world through the same negative lens that they do, including people who will honor their word above all else. And there's more of them than you might think.

(Btw, I didn't downvote you. I wish people wouldn't use the downvote button to express differing opinions; that's what comments are for.)

Re:What makes for a stable marriage? by jjoonathan on Saturday October 11, 2014 @01:11PM (#8442688)
> Friends of mine that come from family backgrounds with a lot of divorce have the same view that you do.

I come from a family with a history of long, strong marriages. My parents are another success story. They have learned to tolerate each other, and we (my parents, my sister, myself) are all better for it.

What do I base my opinion on?

1. My parents fought on occasion. Screaming matches, passive aggression, shit-talking behind each others backs. It was rare and not nearly enough to threaten the marriage, but it gave me a point of comparison.

2. I had friends whose parents did this constantly. Rather than fighting 5% of the time, they fought 95% of the time. I saw some of it first hand.

3. I had friends whose parents were divorced. It wasn't ideal and it created more than a few miscommunications, but the kids got the attention they needed, they didn't complain about their parents trying to take their anger out on them, and things generally seemed to work out OK.

By "filling in the blanks" in my friend's description of #2 with my own experiences of parental fighting (#1), I believe #2 is a considerably worse state of affairs for all involved than #3.

> projection

Right back at you.

> cheaters, liars project

We are in complete agreement on this point :P

I think we would both agree that there is a "you get out what you put in" effect in marriage. More tolerance and more commitment from either partner greatly increase the strength of the marriage and are generally a good thing. My contentions are that there's a turning point where this stops being true and that contract verbiage is poor at determining this turning point and providing appropriate guidance.

Re:What makes for a stable marriage? by Natsu on Saturday October 11, 2014 @01:03PM (#8442657)
That's called 'projection' and I know what you mean. If you're put into a Prisoner's Dilemma with someone who believes that people always cheat, it's not hard to understand what they will do.
Re:What makes for a stable marriage? by ezy on Sunday October 12, 2014 @05:58PM (#8446731)
I think you're a little quick on the trigger, it's not just cheaters who assume that people cheat, it's also people who have been cheated upon or lied to.

In general, I think this is asymmetrical. People who have never had to deal with complexity in their lives, tend to assume that people can live by simple rules. Until they discover that the world doesn't work that way. Usually by getting their naive ass bitten.

They don't call them realists for no reason. (Yes, I know, spoken like a realist :-)). I don't place much value on the opinions of people who tell me how perfect they or their family is -- usually they avoid digging too far into the fascade because their self-worth is tied to how well they and their group (family) perform whatever role they are holding up as ideal.

Re:What makes for a stable marriage? by disallusioned42 on Saturday October 11, 2014 @12:42PM (#8442587)
> Everyone who gets married knows that the possibility of divorce exists and roughly what divorce proceedings entail.

On the contrary, I had absolutely no idea how difficult divorce proceedings were when I got married. Maybe I was just naive and living in a bubble, but it was a very real shock to me that, since our divorce was amiable, my wife and I couldn't just go in to the courthouse and tell them we didn't want to be married any more. Instead the legal system forces an adversarial process on you.

Maybe this was just because my religious ideals caused me to not even consider divorce as an option. But even then, it's a very real thing and I'm pretty sure I'm not the only person to have been in that boat.

Re:What makes for a stable marriage? by jasonparker on Saturday October 11, 2014 @11:17AM (#8442358)
Gotta disagree with you: marriage is a contract, forsaking all others, so long as you both shall live. Divorce means your word is worthless, and that your own wants are more important than your word.

It IS a personal failure, but go ahead, rationalize all you want.

Re:What makes for a stable marriage? by king_jester on Saturday October 11, 2014 @12:19PM (#8442510)
> marriage is a contract, forsaking all others, so long as you both shall live

Not everyone views marriage as a contract or as something that cannot be broken ever. The legal status of marriage in a jurisdiction != how people feel about and treat marriage.

> Divorce means your word is worthless, and that your own wants are more important than your word.

Giving your word on something isn't a clause that requires you to give up your own wants and needs. For example, if you married someone and one day they become abusive, you are not obligated to stay and take said abuse.

> It IS a personal failure, but go ahead, rationalize all you want.

This attitude is so unhelpful and smacks of a superiority complex.

Re:What makes for a stable marriage? by ska on Saturday October 11, 2014 @11:35AM (#8442387)
One part of what marriage is, is a contract between two people. But remember that you don't get to decide the terms of that contract for them.
Re:What makes for a stable marriage? by icebraining on Saturday October 11, 2014 @11:56AM (#8442446)
Gotta disagree with you: marriage is a contract, forsaking all others, so long as you both shall live

Not all marriages are presumed to be "for as long as you shall live". Though they don't usually have a set term, civil marriages (at least around here) are not that tied to Christian values anymore.

Re:What makes for a stable marriage? by disallusioned42 on Saturday October 11, 2014 @08:11PM (#8443828)
People are more important than promises. The only reason we value promises is because they make life in general better for people. I've personally experienced and seen multiple others in the situation where ending the marriage really truly was the best thing for both parties. In these cases, your strict adherence to word/contract is patently absurd and creates nothing but pain and suffering.