Re:Seth Godin takes down pages from Brands in Public
by callmeed on Friday September 25, 2009 @01:10PM
(#843842)
It may not have been in the original article, but someone here on HN stated it best–this is basically a protection racket
From Wikipedia: "A protection racket is an extortion scheme whereby a powerful entity or individual coerces other less powerful entities or individuals to pay protection money which allegedly serves to purchase protection services against various external threats, usually violence or property damage."
Powerful entity: Brands in Public with their authority domain and SEO ranking
Purchase protection services: if you pay BIP, you can edit your page, thereby protecting your reputation.
External threats: in this case, not violence but the PR damage your company might suffer if negative/false information appears on the front of your BIP page.
Re:Seth Godin takes down pages from Brands in Public
by hegemonicon on Friday September 25, 2009 @01:23PM
(#843877)
According to the blog post the pages made were all "samples", presumably to demonstrate the service. Fairly shifty, but now that they're taken down and the only way to get one is by request, there doesn't seem to be much to complain about.
The criticisms of the original project, at least the ones I read, didn't actually do this. Instead people were complaining because it reminded them of something unethical that someone else had done, or they didn't think it fit Seth's personal brand, or they were afraid he would do something unethical in the future, or they never liked him to begin with.
Now if people are saying, "you violated X rule of ethics" then it's really easy to apologize for doing that. But in this case that's not what people were saying, so how exactly do you apologize to those people? Especially since in the end the reason Seth backed down was probably at least in part because his personal brand is worth more than the money he could make from the project anyway, regardless of whether he was right or wrong.