So, from what I can gather, Spolsky and Attwood are:
A) Out of their minds (possible?)
B) Are limited and going to have issues since it's built on the Microsoft stack.
Edit: Also, I didn't know if you knew SO was built on the Microsoft stack, I was asking a legitimate question.
I wouldn't say the two are out of their minds. "Misguided" is more polite, I guess.
Until you can show that using the new Microsoft technology we are talking about (and MVC has only just come out) actually increases development time by a significant factor or some other significant problem, labelling it "improper tooling" is simply identity-based Microsoft hate.
In any case, I'm not arguing with you on the popularity of the two for sure, but I am happy MS is deciding to get their act together and really try to compete, however slow and small their steps are.
Edit: Okay you got me curious, why was this down modded? Was it outside the scope of the conversation? Or was it the comment about Spolsky and Attwood?
I find the "Totals for Active Servers Across All Domains"-graph at the bottom especially intriguing.
Either Microsoft didn't pay their NetCraft-bill, or IIS is falling off a cliff here.