News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Horror of a 'Secure Golden Key' by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @09:36PM (#8430379)
> There's my quick solution. Feel free to further the discussion by critiquing or improving it rather than downvoting to oblivion.

Rather than critiquing your specific solution, allow me to explain why no solution is possible in general.

0. Because this is Apple, people are assuming Apple's model, but it is not acceptable to enshrine that model into legislation for all of the reasons I could go into if they don't seem sufficiently obvious to anyone. And if Cyanogen on a Nexus device or Debian on a PC doesn't support the backdoor (or does but the device owner has the power to remove it), it is clearly unreasonable to hold Apple to a different standard, and in any event would be ineffective because the "criminals" (or anyone desiring privacy) could just use non-Apple devices.

1. Even if you are willing to pass a law against general purpose computing, if you have a backdoor that can't be updated you have both a security vulnerability (because flaws can't be fixed) and an ineffective backdoor (because if someone e.g. loses their keys there is nothing you can do about it).

2. If you have a backdoor that can be updated, whatever process is used for updating the backdoor is now a security vulnerability. Having the updates signed by the Director of the FBI and the Pope provides no security because the Director of the FBI and the Pope have neither the expertise nor the time to understand what it is they're signing, and a rubber stamp enforced by digital signatures is still a rubber stamp.

There are no comments on this comment yet.