Re:The Horror of a 'Secure Golden Key'
by Ar-Curunir on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @10:41PM
(#8430542)
It's really sad that this is the case. It's hard to not be pessimistic about the situation when it's put like this. It's also really hard to explain to people why trying to protect this sort of freedom and privacy is important.
No we have not. We thought we did, but authorities knew better. Remember the cipherpunk crackdown, the crypto wars, NSA tampering with standards etc. They were watching us quietly enough.
The real "freedom" existed for a very tiny period between email/news/irc existing and them registering on The Man's radar, which happened fairly quickly (and no thanks to pop media like War Games for popularizing the idea of hordes of teenagers intent on vandalizing essential network infrastructure). The standards developed to respond (PGP, SSL etc) took 15 years to actually get traction (and I bet you're still not using PGP), and as soon as they hit the mainstream, they were attacked and subverted from inside the organizations trying to implement them on a large scale.
The freedom we thought we had was a myth. I think this is an important concept to keep in mind, going in this inevitable political negotiation with authorities. They lied when they told us we were free, and they will lie when they'll tell us that "golden" keys will only be used for good. Like you don't talk to the police without a lawyer, you shouldn't hand your encryption to them without a Schneier in the room.