Re:AIs are now re-writing history
by freehunter on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @01:33PM
(#8422556)
How do you not know it will happen? I haven't used AutoAwesome since just after it was released, but at least back then it was an opt-in. Google didn't just automatically overwrite your pictures, you selected which ones you wanted to make AutoAwesome.
Has that changed?
According to the Google help page referenced in the article, it is on by default, but you are notified when it happens. Pictures aren't overwritten; new ones are added.
Re:AIs are now re-writing history
by nobodysfool on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:19PM
(#8423344)
It hasn't changed at all. I have it enabled, its funny sometimes. The 2013 year end video brought a tear to my eye, and it changed some beach photos by adding in snowflakes (must have thought the white sand was snow).
Re:AIs are now re-writing history
by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @02:26PM
(#8422972)
I should note that I don't have any special information about AutoAwesome, so my knowledge is based on the blog post.
The author seemed to be surprised which makes me think it was unplanned, but I might have just been reading into it.
I also think that Doctorow's dismissal of his concerns as "trivial on the scale" is silly and somewhat arrogant. Automated alteration of a picture to the point of making a new picture non-discernible from an original is a real different thing. In this case it was very subtle, but the application of this could really have some broad impacts. I recall for example the doctored photo from Iranian missile launches [1] or the Egyptian PM red carpet photoshop [2].
Yes this has been going on forever, but automating it makes the impacts really scale quickly.
[1]http://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/07/10/in-an-iranian-im...
[2]http://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/sep/16/mubarak-doctore...