Re:Bank Sends Email to Wrong Gmail User, Sues Google For His...
by mhb on Thursday September 24, 2009 @07:40PM
(#842508)
If anyone could explain a better intuition for this phrase, I would greatly appreciate it.
Consider the example from wikipedia:
Person 1: He is mad right now.
Person 2: How do you know?
Person 1: Well, because he is really angry.
If you think of it in terms of the meaning of beg as evade, then Person 1 is begging the inquiry of Person 2. She is evading it by restating the premise.
Re:Bank Sends Email to Wrong Gmail User, Sues Google For His...
by sofal on Thursday September 24, 2009 @08:44PM
(#842609)
I never noticed that definition of 'beg' before! Thanks for that explanation. My world is a little more coherent now.
Re:Bank Sends Email to Wrong Gmail User, Sues Google For His...
by mhb on Friday September 25, 2009 @08:28AM
(#843332)
http://www.visuwords.com/ is a fun way to find stuff like that.
I have read the Wikipedia article and I understand what the fallacy is, but for the life of me I cannot stretch my imagination enough to accommodate how "begging the question" fits into it.
When I hear "begging the question" I immediately think of the abstract idea of someone actually begging a question for something. When I read about the logical fallacy, it sounds like it comes from "request for the beginning or premise". In my mind, the phrase should then be "begging for the question" which is still a stretch, but at least I can conceptualize it.
Therefore, it always takes me quite a few cycles to remember what "begging the question" really means because of the complete lack of intuitiveness. I also found this to be true for the term "dynamic programming".
If anyone could explain a better intuition for this phrase, I would greatly appreciate it.