Pointing out the reality that investors have likely valued Bitcoin-related startups at a not insignificant percentage of the total value of Bitcoin in circulation, and that the combined valuations given to Bitcoin startups could conceivably exceed the total value of Bitcoin in circulation if Bitcoin's slide continues, is not in and of itself negative.
Obviously, you perceived it as negative because you logically considered the implications of this observation.
> Blockchain.info is a remarkably well designed and implemented site...
I did not comment on the Blockchain website design. I assume you're referring to my comment ("From a technical perspective, the current Bitcoin chart[4] doesn't look good..."). "Technical perspective" refers to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technical_analysis.
That's not really relevant, is it? It's open-source code that does not depend on any central entity. Either it's useful or it isn't - there isn't anything hidden.
> and why?
We do have some hints as to why - Satoshi posted a fair amount in the Bitcoin Talk forums before disappearing, as well as some mailing lists. Here's a reason posted to a mailing list: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/msg099...
Today, it's developed by a number of people who are all reasonably open as to why they're developing it.
Underscoring every positive Bitcoin related news is the implicit solicitation to `invest` in Bitcoin.
Bitcoin's community will evolve in the same way every online community does. It's found some early traction in the form of speculation which has encouraged people to buy and own Bitcoin. Now that a lot of people know what it is and own some, it's easier to test services built with BTC.
Personally, I find the userbase intolerable because it's logically inconsistent. The entire point of the properties of the currency is to drive decentralisation and the end of our dependency on the financial industry and its monopolies... and yet the community cheers every time there's a new bank, or centralised exchange, or processing network, any time a major company starts accepting bitcoin so they don't have to deal with the little shops, or any other proprietary, monopoly-forming system built on top of Bitcoin.
More exposure = more publicity = more people buying in. If there is one thing about the community is consistent about, it's about getting rich off Bitcoin.
Recently there have been plenty of "I'm out" threats on /r/Bitcoin from people who bought lots of coins at $1000 and they can't take it anymore.
I think there are plenty of people who consistently lose money when they try to time any market, let alone the Bitcoin market.
There are some obvious exciting things that can be built with it, and if it would take off it has the potential to level the playing field for payments processors. That can only be good.
Although especially noticeable with Bitcoin, it is in general a prominent flaw of HN, the top comment is always something negative. Maybe its because users here feel thay are smarter by trashing stuff and dont want to be caught liking the wrong stuff, so they upvote whatever negative comment is gaining momentum.
Parent in this case, by the way, is wrong. Blockchain.info is a remarkably well designed and implemented site, if not fully consistent with Bitcoin's spirit, pretty close to it.