News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by taurath on Monday October 06, 2014 @11:57PM (#8419599)
> The main reason I've always remembered this man is because he's one of the few Chinese people in China (that I'm aware of) who actually enjoys making for the sake of making, and not just as a livelihood.

China has 1.35 billion people, and it seems incredibly unimaginative and frankly egotistic to think that you can make generalizations about overall Chinese culture and then just call it a day. The fact is that even "maker" culture in the US where its currently being celebrated (because it makes people money) is made up of a very small percentage of people working in North America - you would not meet nor have heard of a large group of people "making things for the sake of making" in China but it doesn't mean that they don't exist.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by crahrah on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @12:39AM (#8419682)
It's because of comments like this that it's almost impossible to have a critical conversation about culture.

The parent comment is describing a cultural trope that frames the way people behave in that part of the world. There is a lot of pressure to work towards making money. That doesn't mean 100% of people are necessarily following the priorities set out by their society but it does mean that it makes a maker culture much more difficult there. It's inherently counter-cultural.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by chaostheory on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @12:08AM (#8419626)
> China has 1.35 billion people, and it seems incredibly unimaginative and frankly egotistic to think that you can make generalizations about overall Chinese culture

Ok I'm open to being wrong. How about proving me wrong? What parts of my description of Chinese culture are wrong? For one thing it's a pessimistic society hence the photocopy culture (why take a crazy risk for something unknown and original when I can just use someone else's safe and proven ideas?) and lack of open source (why share when I don't immediately benefit while others will for free?).

> The fact is that even "maker" culture in the US where its currently being celebrated (because it makes people money) is made up of a very small percentage of people working in North America

I agree about the small and minority part, people here are mostly about consumption and that needs to change. However, I strongly disagree about the 'because it makes people money' part. You're confusing the West with China. On a whole, people in the maker culture do it for the love and not as a job or lucrative opportunity. Most of the things being made seem unwanted and not polished for the mass market. Have you looked at Make, Instructables, or any of the other maker communities. People share their plans and designs. People do it for fun. They also make stuff as a way of rebelling against set institutions and consumption. (Maybe this is another strike against Chinese culture? Overall they are used to obeying 'emperors', while our culture is used to a near constant state of rebellion against old norms.) Making money for the majority of this idea tribe is mostly an afterthought. This is way different in China.

About the only thing I can think of in China's defense on this issue is that I'm guessing more people and a larger percentage of the population have the ability to make stuff as opposed to people over here which is probably due more to necessity than personal preference. EDIT: One last edit, there is one more thing that I can think of where people in China Make more due to love and pride and not mainly for money: things related to their space program.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by newhouseb on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @02:22AM (#8419877)
> the photocopy culture

I used to spout this phrase (or ones like it) back when 校内/人人 used to look like a pixel-perfect clone of FB. But I think China is growing beyond this phase. There are small things (like the touch to talk in iMessage? WeChat/微信 has had that for ages) and bigger things like the emergence of drones - the FAA just recently allowed filming of TV shows but some of China's most popular shows are already filmed almost entirely from drones (i.e. 爸爸去那儿).

I think as Westerners it's easy to see what's a clone (because it looks the same) and much harder to see what's not (for us without full fluency) because we can't recognize the innovative ideas everyone else in China may already take for granted.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by chaostheory on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @12:05PM (#8421961)
I don't disagree with you concerning the exceptions here and there, since I'm talking about China as a whole. Hopefully one day the small exceptions become the overall norm instead.
Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by 1stop on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @07:19AM (#8420538)
This comment just reads as a passive-aggressive racist rant.

Do you really think people in China do not share?

Do you really think Chinese are 'used' to obeying 'emporers'? Is that because they did 100 years ago? Which emperor do they follow now? (if you answer is the CCP or Xijinping, how is that different to Congress/Obama?)

Is buying a movie off iTunes for $10 more of a rebellion against institutions than p2p-streaming it over PPS?

BYD - Innovative, non-copy cat company (A kind of chinese-mirror of Tesla).

Tencent - Non-copy cat company, crazy amount of innovation and market penetration

So the above invalidates pretty much every point you make about 'chinese culture' being the reason they have no maker community, because it clearly hasn't stopped them from doing all of the things you say they don't do in other areas.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by mmorris on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @09:56AM (#8421086)
>> the CCP or Xijinping, how is that different to Congress/Obama?

Not disagreeing with you that their is real innovation going on in China (I think there is), but I don't think this is a great example. The US Congress and President Obama are all elected officials, whereas Xi Jinping and the CCP are not.

Electing your own leaders is a pretty big deal, thus the protests in Hong Kong.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by coldtea on Thursday October 09, 2014 @01:05AM (#8430903)
>The US Congress and President Obama are all elected officials, whereas Xi Jinping and the CCP are not. Electing your own leaders is a pretty big deal

You'd be surprised. Tons of Americans don't bother to even vote, and when they do they vote for the same old shit parties, that are very much alike except for some token issues.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by chaostheory on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @12:57PM (#8422290)
> This comment just reads as a passive-aggressive racist rant.

I did not post a racist rant. I'm Chinese. Unlike you I'm not blinded by nationalistic, ethnic pride. I'm more open to self-examination of our culture. Apparently to you anything legitimately critical of Chinese culture is 'racist' even though I've posted specific points.

> Do you really think Chinese are 'used' to obeying 'emporers'? Is that because they did 100 years ago? Which emperor do they follow now? (if you answer is the CCP or Xijinping, how is that different to Congress/Obama?)

Xijinping ascended to his throne. Conversely Obama and our Congress are elected officials.

> Do you really think people in China do not share?

Yes when it comes to family. No when it comes to everyone else. This is because it's still a developing nation. Unlike here, most people don't have the relative luxury of an easy life with a decent social net. Who can blame them?

> Is buying a movie off iTunes for $10 more of a rebellion against institutions than p2p-streaming it over PPS?

I think you're forgetting that both P2P and torrents were created here and not in China. Moreover, torrenting is still pretty popular here.

You're right about BYD, but Tencent is just yet another copy cat machine. Tencent's main differentiation is the scope and range of copycatting, and no not all of it is from the West since S Korea and Japan are so close by.

You haven't really disproved that mainland China has an overall culture of obey and follow. The reason that there's not many people who don't fit the opposite mold over there is because most of them left the mainland a long time ago. It was natural for us, since we are descendants of pirates.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by akfanta on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @10:10AM (#8421182)
> Tencent - Non-copy cat company, crazy amount of innovation and market penetration

Wait, what? This is a terrible example. Tencent is anything but innovative. They are notorious for copying ideas from local startups.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by pavelrub on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @06:38AM (#8420409)
> It seems incredibly unimaginative and frankly egotistic to think that you can make generalizations about overall Chinese culture

Why? What does it mean "generalizations about overall Chinese culture"? Are you claiming that in China there is only a collection of small, unrelated cultures, and no shared core? The whole point of the concept of "culture" is to observe that such generalizations do exist, and they drive many common behaviors in societies. That's why sociology of culture (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sociology_of_culture) is a thing.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by 1stop on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @07:03AM (#8420483)
> Are you claiming that in China there is only a collection of small, unrelated cultures, and no shared core?

Are you implying it isn't? I mean there are more than the Han chinese (ethnic culture), and even within that there is are quite varied cultures within the Han. Most people's "chinese generalisations" are generalising about upper-middle class Chinese from the Big 3 cities + Hong Kong. Because they are the majority that migrate.

Shanghai-ese are not like Guangzhou-ese are not like Hong Kong-ese are not like Beijing-ese are not like Taiwanese. But they'd all call themselves Chinese. So yes you can make some fairly mundane observations: "They all use chopsticks", "They like eating rice", "They have an incredibly competitive education system", "They share a common grammar".

But you could make similar observations about "Europe"... and I'm not sure your point still stands at that point :\

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by pavelrub on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @08:08AM (#8420659)
It's usually the case that large cultures can be divided into subcultures (same with ethnic groups). The question isn't whether this is the case, but whether they form a larger culture with shared values and beliefs, and what those beliefs and values are. This is why the words "only" and "no shared core" appear in the question you are replying to. Saying that such generalizations cannot be made or that they only lead only to "mundane observations" is demonstrably false.

The only question is whether the specific observation discussed here is correct.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by chaostheory on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @12:14PM (#8422021)
> there are more than the Han chinese (ethnic culture), and even within that there is are quite varied cultures within the Han. Most people's "chinese generalisations" are generalising about upper-middle class Chinese from the Big 3 cities + Hong Kong. Because they are the majority that migrate.

There's not a huge, ginormous difference between the Han sub-cultures. I know because I'm descended from both a less populous Han subgroup as well as a larger one, and so are my friends and family by marriage. Usually when Chinese people speak of the 'differences', they are just referring to popular stereotypes.

As for the other non-Han ethnic groups, they make up less than 9% of the population. Most of them also don't really consider themselves as Chinese or part of Chinese culture at large (since they aren't really integrated with it - nor are they treated as Chinese) like the Uyghur's which are closer to Turkish people, and the Tibetans and Koreans. In China's defense, this isn't much different from what happens in Japan.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by rdtsc on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @12:41AM (#8419687)
Ok as the gp pointed out. Where are the thousands of open source projects on Github written by Chinese?

> China has 1.35 billion people, and it seems incredibly unimaginative and frankly egotistic

Surely, by your own suggestion, there should be countless examples of open source projects driven from there. Otherwise, their point (even in its generalized form) still stands.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by v-yadli on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @01:58AM (#8419834)
You have to make them speak English first. I mean, for the majority of Chinese people, they don't care about your Github thing...

Edit: I'd suggest you do some research on this: where's all the information hiding in the Chinese internet? - An interesting example is this: http://www.pudn.com/ It works different. Yes you can download stuff for free there, but you have to upload your own stuff to gain credit.

It's just that, things work quite different here in China... All the things you talk about, you have to think whether they stand, first.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by chaostheory on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @11:11AM (#8421580)
> All the things you talk about, you have to think whether they stand, first.

I'm pretty damn sure I know what I'm talking about. For one thing, I'm not blinded by pride. (Going on a tangent, I don't even understand why people seem offended, since this isn't about talent or skill that a lot of mainlanders possess, this is simply about their culture.)

Pudn is a horrible example of Chinese 'open source' because it's not really Chinese open source. It's really just a Chinese search engine for open source projects of which a lot aren't even Chinese.

1. Like you said, you can't even download anything unless you upload something. Why is this important? Because you can't just build something for the sake of building something and sharing, it still has to be out of self interest and self gain.

2. A lot of the serious projects there aren't even projects that are hosted there. Most of them are just other non-Chinese people's projects that are really hosted on github, sourceforge, google code, or some other open source repo site like code plex (i.e. Pudn's users aren't even uploading their own work.) which makes the 'you have to upload something to download something' even more ridiculous.

3. Of the projects that are really hosted there, most of them just look like the result of small homework assignments.

4. It's not really a place for people to collaborate. It's more of file share and search where people find examples to help finish their upcoming trivial homework assignments. They upload their own completed homework assignments so they can download other people's homework. There's nothing special there.

My point stands. Chinese open source is near non-existent, not because of talent; it's because of culture.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by v-yadli on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @10:00PM (#8424967)
I have no idea why you assume that pudn is an example of 'open source' to me. I'm just talking about information. Do you get this now? You are again interpreting my words with a predefined, well, interpreter. Yes I agree with you that open source (in a western perspective somehow) doesn't work in China, as I have stated above, just like they don't care about Github. It means that the collaboration, copy right awareness, etc, etc, they just don't exist.

Months ago I released some kernel patches for Xperia Z2 on github. Nobody forks it or send me pull requests. I then released kernel images to both XDA and a forum in China. It got so hot that even today there're still 100+ replies a day under my thread. Of course in a Chinese-'zombie'-style like "fawefawiefuawsef" to satisfy "reply to download".

You can see how information flows... Someone releases something. Tens of thousands of end users rush to it and disrupt the ambience of communication. Makers then hide themselves, and turn to do something else. Of course sometimes they don't face end users directly. They have their own community (but usually formed as an instant message group or so) and release stuff through delegates, who are usually mods of forums.

Chinese forums is an interesting thing definitely worth taking a look at. Most hardware modders post things there ranging from vehicle modding to custom guitar stomps.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by chaostheory on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @10:12PM (#8430469)
> I'd suggest you do some research on this: where's all the information hiding in the Chinese internet? It's just that, things work quite different here in China...

In your posts (the previous one and your last one) you were essentially saying that mainland Chinese do things differently, but it was just as good. Well I've listed specific reasons as to why it's not as good as the way things are in the West.

Your current example about 100 replies to your post is like the number of projects on csdn.net; it's just not impressive like other things in China like the pace and scope of Chinese construction (e.g. the 3 Gorges dam) or China's ambition for manned moon landings... and again it has nothing to do with skill or talent. It's just mainland Chinese culture.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by v-yadli on Wednesday October 08, 2014 @10:36PM (#8430528)
> but it was just as good

No. Read it again. It's neither good nor bad to me. I'll apologize if my wording is confusing.

> it's just not impressive like other things...

Trivially true. Universally applicable. Nonsense.

> It's just mainland Chinese culture

Agree. What I really want is to expose the underlying details about how things work here. It's not just simply 'different' in one or two parameters. It's not about good or bad. You can say it's bad, I've got no problem with it. But I really want to say that it's interesting, and it's not just China. The fareast countries are similar.

(Well talking about quality do you really think I'm arguing that pudn is good? Chinese open source is good? Why would you assume me that kind of person after all? :-)

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by chaostheory on Thursday October 09, 2014 @01:47AM (#8430989)
> It's neither good nor bad to me. I'll apologize if my wording is confusing.

Ok then I guess I don't understand your point/purpose of posting that then. From my point of view, it seemed like you were providing an argument against what I previously posted.

> What I really want is to expose the underlying details about how things work here.

I think I've already done a good job of that myself ;)

> It's not just simply 'different' in one or two parameters. It's not about good or bad.

It is bad and it's not subtle bad; it's pretty obvious, glaring, and embarrasingly bad. Again here are the reasons why I feel that it's pathetic that China is just one big photocopier:

1. As everyone has already mentioned, most of the population in China are very capable when it comes to anything technical, making stuff, or hacking it. The skill and talent are both there.

2. China dwarfs everyone when it comes to population.

3. Recapping, China has a lot more people than every other country and proportionally it even has a more skilled population due to many factors; yet most of the innovation still happens Outside of China. China always follows. It never leads in innovation.

> But I really want to say that it's interesting, and it's not just China. The fareast countries are similar.

I disagree. I would say that both Japan and Korea are ahead. Japan is still pretty original, and while Korea does some copying for the most part they also innovate (You can even see it in their films and shows).

China's current predicament is the price for having a totalitarian way of life, where too many ideas are censored by the CCP. Maybe one day China can mitigate the lack of creativity by either allowing more freedom or by importing enough foreigners like Singapore... I kind of doubt it though given the CCP's paranoia and the current laws concerning ownership if you're not a citizen.

What will happen in HK will have more repercussions for the mainland than just control and order.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by v-yadli on Thursday October 09, 2014 @04:38AM (#8431351)
> Ok then I guess I don't understand your point

sorry for that. the logic chain is a bit long... I was working on exploiting the problem of the statement "if Chinese people have Maker culture there will be (same_ratio * population_base) open source projects". I should have quoted it there.

Anyway there's one thing clear (for me), that one create and share when he/she stops struggling for living.

So ok here's a better model:

(same_ratio * max(0, non_struggling_population(china))

But given the fact that open source didn't make it here, this one doesn't make sense (because I know that some little portion of this huge base is really not struggling). nevermind:

(get_ratio_by_culture(china) * max( ..... )) ^ `this is what we get at this point.

Ugh, too simple isn't it, I'd really like to see something more interesting.

Let's first not introduce forums, IM groups of producers. Just consider one thing: Chinese people crack things. The more 'struggling' they are, the more they crack, but the skill gets lower. Say that now we have a close source binary. Some top-notched hackers extracted/disassembled the code to make it more readable, and runnable. (Maybe they're from Russia, just sayin :-D Lower tier programmers bind hooks to the routines. Lower tier programmers use editors to iterate through the binary to seek for useful literals, inject resources to make mods... Lower tier resellers, though not capable of these technical stuff, are able to follow the tutorials released by all higher tiers, and subtly modify the thing.

And this model suddenly becomes a non-deterministic close-source-binary cracking ecosystem, that tries many possible solutions simultaneously, and hierarchically(given the fan-out factor high enough between each two tiers).

Yeah I know you would never say this is "good". But I think this is at least mathematically interesting. And it gives some sense to how to utilize this kind of ecosystems to do something real(though this model is still far from realistic).

> I would say that both Japan and Korea are ahead

Sure. Just consider get_ratio_by_culture() and non_struggling_population().

get_ratio_by_culture() is similar. It doesn't mean the current whole picture is similar. But the later one is variable and the former one is nearly const.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by chaostheory on Thursday October 09, 2014 @12:10PM (#8433275)
Here's the thing. Having a majority lower class population is a not a good excuse for the lack of innovation. In the 19th century, approximately 80% of the population in the West was working class. You can say that the population more closely mirrors China's population today, where the population is poor but very skilled. Despite the disadvantages of most of the population, the West was still extremely innovative.

Another trend that gets exposed here is that anytime anyone has a valid criticism of China, the inevitable "China is still developing" or "Most of China's population is poor" excuse tends to come up.

At the end of the day, the true reason for the lack of mainland Chinese innovation is probably the suppression of freedom by the CCP as well as the culture that is created from a low trust society due to the CCP's corruption. It's hard to be creative when you have to think about what you can and can't say or type, as well as missing out on the ideas that could have been shared, but have not due to the lack of free expression. Unless things change, China will never become much more than a larger and larger photocopier. HK is the first test.

Maybe the only place China can innovate are in sectors that have legal controls in the West like bioengineering.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by noselasd on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @03:16PM (#8423323)
https://code.csdn.net would be a better example. www.pudn.com is where I go looking for code and docs that aren't really supposed to be "open" in any sense.
Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by SavvyGuard on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @11:28AM (#8421694)
You've got to be kidding right? Are you really surprised that an English language site that is sometimes blocked in China and lacks a Chinese language interface doesn't have obviously Chinese contributors? Do you expect a conical hat on the profile pics of all the Chinese contributors? How exactly do you expect to see who's Chinese and who's not on a site like Github?

You can easily check out Chinese language code hosting sites, like

https://code.csdn.net/explore/projects?tag_name=python

Of course, I'm pretty sure that's not going to convince you of anything.

Re:There Is No Maker Movement in China by chaostheory on Tuesday October 07, 2014 @12:32PM (#8422130)
Unlike Pudn, csdn.net seems pretty legit. However it looks like there are only about 8000 projects give or take. Compare this with github which has a few million projects and that's just one repo service I'm not even counting stuff like bitbucket and google code. Again I'm not pointing out a deficiency in skill or talent, this is just about culture.