News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'You Have the Right to Remain Silent.' or Do You? by derefr on Monday October 06, 2014 @01:17PM (#8417005)
It makes more sense in non-verbal cases, I think. I read the suggestion somewhere (that "Illustrated Guide to Law" linked in a sibling comment) that Al Capone could have "plead the fifth" on his tax returns, instead of just not submitting them—and that the government would be required to accept this as a valid return, and do their own investigation of his tax status (whereas they wouldn't need to accept e.g. a blank return.) that sounds contentious to me, so I'd really like to hear what another lawyer thinks of it. If true, it almost explains the need to submit paper forms that are looked at by humans: special-case exceptions like this that override all normal "parsing" of a legal form using a plain-English statement.

There are no comments on this comment yet.