In reality it's the opportunity costs that makes training doctors so expensive. So, in many ways less developed nations have a huge cost advantage when supplying doctors. The real issue is after exporting them they probably don't send all that much money back home.
It's my understanding that this is not the case. That remittance from the US is a pretty significant part of many developing economies [1][2].
I've yet to a met an immigrant professional in the US who didn't send huge amounts back home along with itent or at least hope of retiring there.
1: http://www.havanatimes.org/?p=94444 2: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-12-17/global-immigrants-s...
But I guess they may return separately.
Developed countries have medical doctors associations which keep a close eye on who can become doctor and how, thus limiting the number of doctors in the country and sustaining their high wages.
From what I've heard, you have to get an expensive education and then live thru a long and undercompensated and exhausting internship in order to become a full doctor and get all the perks. Any immigrant will also have to face that kind of internship (not easy for someone without a source of income) plus they have to re-learn a lot of things in order to pass the certification.
I might be fuzzy on the details, but still: we're lucky in our IT, we have comparative small amount of bullshit and entrenching.
That's completely ridiculous. Developed countries actively import doctors, going so far as to genuinely trying to lure them by advertising the kinds of salaries they can get.
Countries like Sweden, Norway, Germany, etc. now get significant numbers of their dcotors from abroad. Because their own population doesn't provide enough doctors. Additionally, the foreign ones tend to be cheaper (both because they're paid less but also because you don't need to put them through education).
It's so extreme that in some developing countries of Europe, half the doctors leave for the above-mentioned developed countries.
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/9647519c-207a-11e3-b8c6-00144feab7...
Doctors tend to leave undeveloped countries for developed countries.
http://www.plosmedicine.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fj...
This changes the perspective slightly.
http://www.cepr.net/index.php/blogs/beat-the-press/rewriting...
"Any discussion of an alleged shortage of doctors in the United States should include an account of the doctors' efforts to create this shortage to keep their salaries high. It is also striking that, unlike the case of STEM workers, nurses, or farm workers, no one discusses bringing in more foreign doctors to alleviate this shortage. There would be hundreds of thousands, perhaps millions, of foreign physicians who would be happy to train to U.S. standards and work for even half of the pay that doctors get in the United States. This would reduce the cost of health care in the United States, freeing up tens of billions of dollars to be spent in other areas creating hundreds of thousands of jobs.
"And, we do know how to ensure that importing more foreign doctors does not hurt health care in the developing world. If the income taxes paid by foreign trained doctors were transferred to their home country, they could easily train 2-3 doctors for every doctor that came to the United States. This would ensure that developing countries gained from this arrangement as well."
edit:
Path to United States Practice Is Long Slog to Foreign Doctors
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/12/business/economy/long-slog...
"The biggest challenge is that an immigrant physician must win one of the coveted slots in America’s medical residency system, the step that seems to be the tightest bottleneck.
"That residency, which typically involves grueling 80-hour workweeks, is required even if a doctor previously did a residency in a country with an advanced medical system, like Britain or Japan. The only exception is for doctors who did their residencies in Canada.
"The whole process can consume upward of a decade — for those lucky few who make it through."
The flux of Asian immigration in the 60s, after the caps on these countries were lifted, was focused on skilled labor where there was limited US supply. AKA doctors.
We in the US still have this eye towards immigration of the skilled. While it is currently less in the medical field, it continues due to the lack of services in rural areas.
In Europe many Romanian doctors leave Romania and make much better wages in England and other countries. In India and so many other countries, many left for the US. Being a doctor had social weight and financial weight that it no longer carries here, in the US.
This is untrue in almost all situations that I'm aware of, other than nursing and IT.
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/12/business/economy/long-slog...
"'It took me double the time I thought, since I was still having to work while I was studying to pay for the visa, which was very expensive,' said Alisson Sombredero, 33, an H.I.V. specialist who came to the United States from Colombia in 2005.
"Dr. Sombredero spent three years studying for her American license exams, gathering recommendation letters and volunteering at a hospital in an unpaid position. She supported herself during that time by working as a nanny. That was followed by three years in a residency at Highland Hospital in Oakland, Calif., and one year in an H.I.V. fellowship at San Francisco General Hospital. She finally finished her training this summer, eight years after she arrived in the United States and 16 years after she first enrolled in medical school.
"Dr. Sombredero was helped through the process by the Welcome Back Initiative, an organization started 12 years ago as a partnership between San Francisco State University and City College of San Francisco. The organization has worked with about 4,600 physicians in its centers around the country, according to its founder, José Ramón Fernández-Peña.
"Only 118 of those doctors, he said, have successfully made it to residency.
"'If I had to even think about going through residency now, I’d shoot myself,' said Dr. Fernández-Peña, who came to the United States from Mexico in 1985 and chose not even to try treating patients once he learned what the licensing process requires."
Also, I've never hear about the IMF forcing a country to dismantle its public-education programs. When Brazil was on their hook they did anything but that, and in the later years IMF helped improving it.
For instance, in Ukraine a few years ago, the IMF's advice was to cut down on some structural expenses (gas subsidies mostly) and not to touch investment expenses as doing that would trigger a recession.
For political reasons IMF did the opposite.
I have grandparents, aunts and uncles who were all trained at Adventist medical institutions, and spent time working at hospitals in 3rd world countries. The Adventist church has its own medical school, as well as a health system (though neither is directly operated by the church).
I took a "student missions" year out of college (somewhat like Mormon mission years, only typically more a religiously-driven piece-corps-type year of teaching, medical assistance etc. than direct-evangelism) and spent it in Belize volunteering at a hospital. 3 of the hospital's 5 physicians were Cubans, and I learned first-hand that Cuba and the Adventist church have remarkably similar strategies when it comes to training doctors, and using them as a PR tool.
In both cases it seems to be quite effective. In Belize, many people I met thought highly of Cuba, because their most direct interaction was through the doctors they sent. Even here in the states, when the Adventist church is mentioned I'll often hear, "Oh, I think my Doctor is one of those."
Not just medical personnel, in the 60s they were one of the biggest provider of trained personnel in general in the newly independent congo (before being forced out as Zaïrisation ramped up) to both staff the country and provide training (Belgium had avoided/refused to establish a local elite, so when they hightailed the newly independent Congo had no administrators, no teachers, no doctors, …)
And all that from an island despite US's decades-long embargo and forcing the criminal Guantanamo Bay prison on them.
There is a direct tech analogy with Finland and cell phones.
From the small country PoV, if you can't compete in the strategic nuclear bomber world market, or the manufacturing robot world market, you can probably find some market segment, however small, to focus on and take over. Like cellphones, or 3rd world medical care.
Other countries could, and probably will, do the same.
There is the interesting analogy that Finland isn't doing so well in the post Nokia, iphone and android world. Wonder what could happen to Cuba if the demand for docs dried up (optimistically due to 3rd world advancing into training their own medical workers, and not by the entire 3rd world dying of ebola or in ensuing strife after the epidemic)