News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by JeremyMorgan on Sunday October 05, 2014 @12:21AM (#8411426)
I think this is a good move.

I understand the tax incentives/accounting behind it, but I still feel it's kind of shady to hire "contractors" for positions that are indefinite. I think contractors should be for the time you need a bunch of hands or brains to get something done for a few months, but using contractors for years on end is just abuse of the system and demeaning for the person.

Who do you think is going to be more loyal and do a better job with your security, someone who always feels like an outsider, or someone who is protecting "their" own company?

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by enneff on Sunday October 05, 2014 @12:35AM (#8411455)
I guess part of the rationale for using contractors for, say, kitchen workers is that you can use a consulting firm with expertise in catering, rather than having to develop that expertise in-house.
Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by vanadium on Sunday October 05, 2014 @01:34AM (#8411540)
Or you could just hire a single person with domain expertise as a consultant for a given time to staff the group and end up with a presumably high-quality in-house kitchen staff from the start. The consultant moves onto their next gig after making sure the pieces fit as intended.

This is a pretty common use case for the better consultants out there.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by ubershmekel on Sunday October 05, 2014 @01:46AM (#8411560)
I have to assume certain companies want to stay focused. This has many ramifications. E.g. if you're unhappy with the guards/cooks/cleaning - replacing that entire part of the organization is as easy as the contract makes it. If that operation is in-house - replacing employees, reforming, finding the talent to do that is much harder than window shopping for a competing third party to take over.

Should a water company have an in-house pipe factory?

Should a game dev company have in-house hardware fabrication?

Should a food factory have an in-house plastic packaging factory?

These questions don't have a clear answer in my opinion.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by A1kmm on Sunday October 05, 2014 @02:35AM (#8411625)
In most of your examples, the answer is no because of economies of scale; hardware fabrication only makes sense because of economies of scale (and to a lesser extent pipe or packaging production - although you could ask the same question about vertical integration all the way up the petrochemical supply chain to operating oil rigs and refineries).

Most game dev companies just aren't big enough to need enough hardware for vertical integration to make sense. Most water companies aren't big enough for a pipe factory to be economically viable, let alone building their own minerals division, oil rigs, oil refinery and chemical plants.

I suspect that security and running cafeterias do have economies of scale (e.g. a business might only need a drive-by check a few times a night, and so it is more efficient to have one guard drive around different businesses than for each business to hire their own guard), but Google's demands for security and cafeteria services are probably high enough that they gain many of the same benefits of the economy of scale.

Allowing management to focus on core competencies is also important for smaller businesses, but eventually most decision-making is delegated to middle managers or even subsidiary companies, so the top tier of management doesn't have to worry about it. For big companies like Google, it is likely that they have modelled it, and worked out it will cost them less to vertically integrate this function.

Businesses generally have far more efficient control over employees than contractors, so if they are unhappy with something, they can just change it rather than needing to renegotiate a contract.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by vanadium on Sunday October 05, 2014 @01:56AM (#8411579)
It was a hypothetical and tangential case based on the parent comment, so let's get back to the original context where there is a more clear-cut conclusion.

When it comes to security, the accountability dynamic between personal investment in outcomes and the inherent detachment as an employee of a third party is a bit different than kitchen work, and significantly more important.

This arrangement works to the benefit of both Google and those responsible for securing the company.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by walshemj on Sunday October 05, 2014 @08:11AM (#8412082)
Agreed I worked for large Telco and we had an office in Manchester cleaned out of PC's twice in year - turns out it was an inside job on of the outsourced security guards let them in.

I was involved in the replacement for the third time (we used all the old crap pc's we could dig up from across the company)

And given the high profile espionage that goes on in sv and tech having direct control and vetting of security guards makes sense.

Of course for the more secret squirrel side of the biz we always used different security - ask yourself when Bruce Scheier left BT note who he as very careful to be ltra nice to on the way out.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by xorcist on Sunday October 05, 2014 @04:48AM (#8411802)
Over a certain size it starts to make sense to vertically integrate your business. If you are big, say Apple, creating your own hardware allows you to do better and differentiate against your competitors. It may also allow you to cut off resources for your competitors (see for example oil companies).

A company such as Valve is probably on the fence on this. They dominate a small segment of the market, but is not really big enough to do something their competitors can't replicate.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by nknighthb on Sunday October 05, 2014 @01:38AM (#8411548)
Or just buy a catering company. Annual profits in the billions leaves a company with no shortage of options.
Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by tehwebguy on Sunday October 05, 2014 @11:02AM (#8412437)
They aren't using the independent contractor tax option (1099) to pay individuals, they are contracting a company that has employees.

This position would never pass as a 1099

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by tn13 on Monday October 06, 2014 @05:32AM (#8414952)
- Who do you think is going to be more loyal

I think the person who knows for sure that he will be fired for not doing his job properly will be more loyal.

I don't think it is a wise decision for any company to employ security guards as they own employees. It makes much more sense to let a third company specialized in security recruit, train and contract guards to Google. Is Google in a better position to do background verification, recruit, train and maintain large number of security guards ? Is is a good way to spend their profits ? The answer might be yes or not but it has nothing to do with "demeaning for the person" and other rhetorical reasons.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by ownagefool on Sunday October 05, 2014 @05:17AM (#8411838)
I guess that depends on location. Personally, in the UK, I wouldn't dream of being a perm employee. Contract is the only way you can hire me.

You can't really say a company is deemening me by holding on to me as long as possible.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by JCole on Sunday October 05, 2014 @05:59AM (#8411896)
What are the advantages of contract work in the UK?
Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by ownagefool on Sunday October 05, 2014 @09:37AM (#8412238)
As others have commented, you trade the perception of job security for much higher pay and tax breaks. Companies will let you go when they no longer have work for you, but finding work isn't hard for someone resonably talented.
Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by davidgerard on Sunday October 05, 2014 @01:55PM (#8412884)
In IT? Buckets of money, and a ridiculously low tax rate. When I was contracting, I actually felt guilty at how little tax I was paying (about 9% effective, as opposed to about 30% typical for a wage).

Downside: binge-and-purge income (this is why I gave it up). Shitty work for shitty people - where there's muck there's brass, and where there's muck there's contractors cleaning out IT toilets that haven't been cleaned in years.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by russell_h on Sunday October 05, 2014 @03:50PM (#8413248)
What is the rationale for the lower tax rate?

I'm mostly curious because in the US it is somewhat the opposite - employers are required to pay a tax for every employee, so if you are self-employed your tax rate actually goes up.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by davidgerard on Sunday October 05, 2014 @03:54PM (#8413256)
Because they pay your umbrella company, something something corporate magic.

I think the real reason is that the tax system is biased to the already well off.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by tlarkworthy on Sunday October 05, 2014 @09:07PM (#8413956)
yeah, you get the money out the umbrella company via dividends rather than salary.
Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by tankenmate on Sunday October 05, 2014 @06:37AM (#8411945)
As long as you can legally avoid some of the issues surrounding IR35 (taxation rule, not law, specifying who is a contractor and who is an employee) and know the rules about pay vs dividends you can pay significantly less tax.
Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by walshemj on Sunday October 05, 2014 @08:28AM (#8412121)
A lot less even on an umbrella (akin to a w2) you make a lot more that a permanent employee. It always surprised me how poorly paid American contractors are relative to full timers.

One chap on Stack over flow seemed to think a 15% premium was a good deal id be looking for 50 - 100% - I looked at a 6 moth contract for Perl at companies house and at the day rate I would have gone in at £400) I would have been on £100k Gross and around 80K after Tax.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by bad_user on Sunday October 05, 2014 @06:36AM (#8411942)
Probably less taxes.
Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by gaius on Sunday October 05, 2014 @09:10AM (#8412189)
Yes it is a nationwide scandal, in IT, media, even the civil service and the BBC. If it looks like an employee and quacks like an employee then it should be taxed like an employee.
Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by Nursie on Sunday October 05, 2014 @10:21AM (#8412312)
No it is not a scandal and no I am not an employee. I have no expectation of ongoing work. I come in, I get going fast, I work efficiently and smartly and I leave when the project is done.

Very different ballgame to permanent employment. Permanent work also pays really badly as a rule.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by Joeboy on Sunday October 05, 2014 @10:37AM (#8412359)
As long as "when the project is done" is a reasonable length of time (ie. weeks or months, not years) then I'd say you're not quacking like an employee.

I don't think working efficiently and smartly is a good criterion for judging whether or not you quack like an employee.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by Nursie on Sunday October 05, 2014 @11:35AM (#8412519)
Well given the standard of perm workers I've been around lately... it seems to be a different mindset and good contractors seem more aware they're there to get the job done.

YMMV of course. And yes, I tend to find six months is a good timespan, project dependent of course. I know there are contractors who hang around at places for years, that seems like something different.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by walshemj on Sunday October 05, 2014 @03:40PM (#8413217)
No that was the contract for personnel services scam not IT contracting which is treated far less fairly than say accountants or lawyers.
Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by kamjam on Monday October 06, 2014 @10:08AM (#8415898)
In IT maybe, but those security guards are probably permanent employees of the firm that Google sub-contracted their security to. So reality they may just be moving from being a permanent employee of Acme Security Corp to that of Google.

It seems they get more benefits being a Google employee though (from TFA at least).

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by sidcool on Sunday October 05, 2014 @01:20AM (#8411517)
That exactly was my first thought...'What's in it for Google?'. Not doubting their good intentions, but whenever any corporate portrays an altruistic thing, it rings the skeptic bell in my head.

Good move Google.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by bostik on Sunday October 05, 2014 @04:53AM (#8411812)
I don't understand the downvote, because I can easily think of non-altruistic reasons for this move.

1) I have no doubt Google already tracks their contractors' staff turnover. Every industry has institutional knowledge, and if staff turnover is high, not enough of the knowledge gets transferred. If the prestige of being a Googler is enough to counter that trend, it may be well worth a lot more than the monetary cost.

2) Assuming the detail about "gbus" access is true, the security guards traveling on the buses will have personal incentives for keeping them safer.

3) This move may attract the kinds of people Google wants for their physical security. (Related to point #1.)

So while Google may well be riding the social awareness wave for PR purposes, there are bound to be real corporate reasons behind the move too.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by wavegeek on Monday October 06, 2014 @01:33AM (#8414419)
You might find it also makes their stats look better ie % African American employees.

Don't be evil.*

*Unless it's profitable.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by 001sky on Sunday October 05, 2014 @08:01PM (#8413833)
This is a cheap way to buy "token minority positions" and increase the appearance of diversity.

Its a smart, if somewhat cynical move.

http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/11/the-work...

"Blacks, who make up just 11 percent of the workforce, account for more than a third of home health aides and about 25 percent of both security guards and bus drivers—rather low paying jobs."

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by ufmace on Sunday October 05, 2014 @05:18PM (#8413489)
Part of the reason may be a PR thing - they want to improve their image so that there are less people, say, protesting their busses and employees.
Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by Alex3917 on Sunday October 05, 2014 @08:02AM (#8412069)
Avoiding lawsuits for racial discrimination.
Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by frostmatthew on Sunday October 05, 2014 @09:26AM (#8412220)
If you're suggesting what I think you are (that they're doing this for a bump in their diversity numbers) it should be noted their diversity report[1] breaks it down by tech and non-tech.

[1] http://www.google.com/diversity/at-google.html#tab=tech

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by 001sky on Sunday October 05, 2014 @08:05PM (#8413838)
non-tech black = 3%

black national % of security guards = 20%

every little bit helps I guess

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by xorcist on Sunday October 05, 2014 @04:44AM (#8411796)
Common sense suggests that this way should be cheaper, too. The contractor is often twice as expensive as their salary, so if you want them for an extended period of time it would make economic sense for a rational actor to hire directly.

This is however offset by economic realities, where two equal cost may have a very different impact of valuation. So it does make economic sense to pay more for a cost that is not counted as a fixed cost of doing business on the accounting sheets.

Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by walshemj on Sunday October 05, 2014 @03:42PM (#8413228)
err these are minimum wage security guards employed by a contractor not self employed contractors in their own right
Re:Google to Make Security Guards Employees, Rather Than Con... by cpwright on Monday October 06, 2014 @07:59AM (#8415386)
And the contracting company certainly takes a cut of every hour Google is paying for. Assuming the security guards get the same benefits as other Googlers (and they should), I would expect that Google saves very little money, or maybe even spends more; but the guards themselves should have a much more valuable pay package without the security company skimming off the top [I don't begrudge the security company, but it does seem a nicer overall solution in this case to cut out the middle man].