I think "duct tape programmer" should be derogatory, while "practical programmer" or "pragmatic programmer" would be more apt for Joel's idols.
Most of the piece seems to be about the benefits of keeping it simple and doing the obvious thing that will work rather than outsmarting yourself. All well and good advice, easily applicable by anyone with the confidence to face down blowhards that would rather things feed their leet-programmer ego than actually meet a customer's need.
But then it goes into not writing tests and doing complicated bit-munging to save a bit of time or space (both of which you think would be the opposite of the previous advice of keep it simple and accept your own human failings) and which is stuff that you can only get away with if you are both talented and lucky.
If he dropped the last paragraph and the bit about not writing unit tests (which, the theory goes, will save you time assuming, again, that you're not a lucky genius) then this would hold together somewhat coherently.
So what's his point? Be talented.
Still, it was nice to see him get excited about something not directly in that vein.
Edit: It was also by reading a Spolsky post way back when that I originally discovered PG's essays. So I can't ever get too mad at him.
It's definitely one of the things I'm most impressed about with 37s and Fog Creek, that they've managed to extract so much business value out of their blogs.
Reading Spolsky back in '03-'04 was what made me want to become a product manager, which I was pretty quickly able to do, which experience taught me what little I know now about the software business (you know, besides actually writing and shipping code, and, uh, getting funding, neither of which appear to have any correlation with success in the business ;] ).
I actually think Spolsky's weakest on the hard tech content, and strongest on the product marketing side.
I agree about Spolsky & Co. not being that technically strong, which is a little ironic given how much he's written about attracting the best programmers, etc. Still, although I don't read him regularly, I almost always enjoy when I do. And a lot of what he says about the software business is really helpful. Chris Dixon linked to a post of his the other day about lowering the price of complementary products which was a great example.
Uh... wasn't that his affiliate amazon link? If he gets a cut each time somebody buys the book he keeps telling us to buy, isn't it still his marketing?
Duct tape programmers have to have a lot of talent to pull off this shtick.
In other words what matters is talent, not duct tape. Untalented duct tape programmers do as much damage as the untalented design-pattern programmers he scourges. So what was the point again?