"it's not their fault most of the time"?
The people in this country most oppressed by crime are not well-off conservative white people. Crime is a scourge of low-income communities, and most of it is violent.
Re:Three Years on Rikers Without Trial
by swartkrans on Friday October 03, 2014 @02:56AM
(#8404570)
I was simply saying that victims are most often not to blame for being a victim. I didn't expect that to be a controversial statement.
We've not yet decided if the system exists for punishment or rehabilitation, until we the people decide, this sort of thing will be depressingly common.
Re:Three Years on Rikers Without Trial
by swartkrans on Friday October 03, 2014 @02:57AM
(#8404571)
Yes I was making an argument for rehabilitation I think. Also I made a typo, I meant not impartial.
http://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_36,_Changes_in...
The entire thing, including the original story the parent comment, is Kafka-esque. We need massive prison reform.
Victim's rights are such a sham. I don't want to attack victims, it's not their fault most of the time, but nobody would think a court would be fair if the jury were comprised of victims because victims are inherently impartial due to their suffering. Victims are unreasonable, and punishment of the offender does nothing to undo the harm they've done so I think instead of considering victim rights we should consider what's best for society instead, which probably involves rehabilitation. I'm not sure that except in the most extreme circumstances someone should ever go to prison for 15+ years. After 15 years in jail, with focus on rehabilitation, I doubt most would go back to crime. No you wont get punishment and suffering out of the offender for the crime, but that's a stupid thing to want in the first place.