News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The 10,000 Hour Rule for deliberate practice is wrong by kazinator on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @05:36PM (#8397914)
There is also the problem that not all 10,000 hour blocks of time are equal, because there are efficient ways to practice and there are inefficient ways.

Everyone (non-piano-players too) should read C. Chang's book "Fundamentals of Piano Practice".

http://www.pianofundamentals.com/book

There is a free PDF here:

http://www.pianopractice.org/

It is quite fascinating reading. One of the main points is that to practice effectively, do not waste your time playing pieces over and over again. A 50 bar piece might contain only one bar that gives you trouble. If you play the piece over and over again, you will only encounter that bar 1 in 50 times. If you just play that bar, you will be practicing the difficult part nearly 50X faster.

You can use a metronome to identify "stress points". These show up when you gradually increase tempo. Perhaps at 80 beats per minute, you can get through the piece, but around 95 b.p.m. there are places where you start to fumble. Those are the stress points to focus on.

Another fascinating observation or insight of the author is about speed. You can play a run of several notes infinitely fast with ease: namely, just strike them at the same time as a chord. There, infinitely fast! So it's actually the in-between speeds that are troublesome; it's not true that difficulty strictly increases with speed.

In fact, insanely fast phrases are actually played as chords, with staggered timing. The hand comes down to play all the notes, but they are offset so they start at different times.

He regards this backwards: start at infinite speed (playing the chord) and then it's just a matter of slowing it down from there: stagger the notes so they sound individually.

Pure genius!

There are no comments on this comment yet.