Re:Atom: Editor window startup is slow
by Cthulhu_ on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @10:27AM
(#8394551)
Your post reminds me of when Chrome was first released, and how startup time (and speed in general) was one of their primary concerns. They had (and probably still have) a whole suite of performance tests that, amongst other things, measure startup time.
With that in mind, if they didn't have those optimizations, Atom would probably be an order of magnitude slower to start up than it is today. It's all a matter of non-functional requirements and priorities, I guess.
On the other hand: as the saying goes, "make it work, make it pretty, make it fast" - which can be interpreted in various ways, like "working software is more important than fast software" (aka avoid premature optimization), and "a well-designed application is easy to optimize".
Re:Atom: Editor window startup is slow
by HelloNurse on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @03:58PM
(#8397282)
For an intensely interactive application such as a text editor, performance is part of "make it work".
If the screen is lagging behind keypresses, or trivial commands (e.g. the mentioned reordering of tabs) take long enough to wonder whether the program is hung, the basic contract of user interface has been broken.
Basing the core of a text editor (not only scripting, as in Emacs, but input, rendering, event handling, data structures) on low-performance technology is as wrong as, say, designing it for single-byte character sets only.
Re:Atom: Editor window startup is slow
by chriswarbo on Wednesday October 01, 2014 @11:05AM
(#8394965)
> as the saying goes, "make it work, make it pretty, make it fast"
OT: I've not actually heard that stated before. I've seen "make it work, make it work correctly, (if you have the time) make it work fast"
Maybe I shouldn't be allowed near front-end stuff ;)
Startup speed matters, sometimes a lot, sometimes not so much. It is both interesting because optimizations are a common problem in our field and the different approaches that can be taken are interesting to discuss, but it is also interesting taking a look at how this particular project cares about startup speed and what they have decided to prioritize over it (the social / project management aspect).