News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple takes down another indie dev by kijeda on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @11:32AM (#8388738)
The article essentially chronicles surprise that this app would be rejected. What you describe is you believe the terms are unjust. These are two different things.

I may not agree with the speed limit on the freeway, but I am not surprised if I am ticketed for going over it.

Re:Apple takes down another indie dev by pgodzin on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @11:54AM (#8388899)
A big issue is that the app was approved in the first place. If I'm having an emergency and a cop stops me and says it's fine to speed, then tickets me a mile later, I would be surprised.
Re:Apple takes down another indie dev by pflats on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @02:41PM (#8390220)
What happened here, though, is that the cop said it's fine to speed, and then his boss saw you speeding a mile later.

I agree that Apple should have never approved the app in the first place. Once they let it through, there was no good solution.

1. Allow all widget launchers, which they don't want and are explicitly against the TOS.

2. Allow only this widget app to stay, giving it an unfair monopoly. Cue kingmaker article.

3. Allow this version of the widget app to stay, reject all updates. Like #2, but worse in every way.

4. Pull the app off the store; allow it to continue to function for people to have it.

5. Push the big red button to pull the app off the store and every phone.

Any time a flagrant TOS violation sneaks through, whether by App Review oversight or by subterfuge, this happens. Apple always chooses #4.

Re:Apple takes down another indie dev by kgarten on Tuesday September 30, 2014 @12:31PM (#8389158)
Not really the right comparison ... more like: you pass a speed control without being flashed and in the next mile you get a ticket. That can happen.