The idea is to have a common UI and REST API for building packages and managing repositories across packaging toolchains. Right now it supports rpm+yum and deb+apt. Packages are built in isolated Linux containers using Heroku's buildpack interface. (Would love feedback from anyone who's interested in beta testing.)
Also, have you seen the Omaha protocol?
https://code.google.com/p/omaha/wiki/ServerProtocol
It's used by a lot software, including Chrome and ChromeOS. Recently, CoreOS has built infrastructure with it and they offer a SaaS product for rolling updates. I think they're planning on using it to update Docker containers, too:
The only result will inevitably be that we'll have yet another package manager.
"devDependencies": {
"bower": ">=1.3"
},
"scripts": {
"postinstall": "bower install"
}
This way I never need a global install of bower, nor do I ever really need to use it directly. I don't see why something similar couldn't be set up for any other npm-able package manager or build tool. A bit of googling seems to indicate that npm can update node using e.g. the "n" module. That module or another like it can of course be a dependency in package.json.I get that having a standard format (let's say "dependencies", "devDependencies", and "peerDependencies" as properties of a json file) would make somebody's life easier, but it's not clear that is the same set of somebodies who develop and use all these package managers.
Because dependency management is a separate problem from building. I need to be able to see what, exactly, every package depends on, and to be able to operate on that, to be able to deploy my system, and in order to know what exactly it is that I'm running.
Figuring out what my dependencies are at the same time as building my system leads to near-constant breakage, and I couldn't even figure out "am I using this package somewhere or not?" because there's no central package database when using npm/pypi/whatever else. How am I supposed to figure out whether my system is secure if I can't figure out what's installed on it to match against the CVE databases?
Today, I solve this with an extremely hackish set of scripts (npm2nix, pypi2nix, etc) and a lot of manual overrides to specify dependencies between bits of code written in different languages, and wrap that into one package database. Operating system distributors are forced to do the same.
> I get that having a standard format (let's say "dependencies", "devDependencies", and "peerDependencies" as properties of a json file) would make somebody's life easier, but it's not clear that is the same set of somebodies who develop and use all these package managers.
As a user of package managers, it would make my life easier if everybody would actually define all their dependencies in such a way that I can run an automated tool against a list of packages and discover every single package, so that I can wrap them into a DVD for offline installation, or figure out whether I'm vulnerable to something, or convert them for use with my own package manager, or whatever else I want to do.
The path to a standard package manager starts with a standardized protocol for package management.
A service protocol that is able to serve a repository of packages over http and ftp. A client protocol that can keep track of installed packages and can index, search and look for updates on installed packages.
Split package management into layers and only try to standardize bit by bit. People will never agree on deb vs rpm. People will never agree on using json vs python vs Makefile vs ruby vs shell vs whatever else - they'll always want their most familiar language for their package manager, which in domain-specific packaging means the domain-specific language.
So don't try to standardize those. Standardize the rest. Give us the protocol that can power all of this and increase interoperability. Separate the repository layer, the package format (deb, rpm), the packagefile format (setup.py, Makefile, PKGBUILD) and the package manager (interface: yum, apt-get, aptitude, pip, npm) from the rest of the protocol.
Make this potentially usable for things such as browser extension repositories, android package management, vim bundles and what not.
Someone please work on this. I'd do it but it just occured to me I have to clean my oven.