Re:Why the Facebook Experiment Is Lousy Social Science
by gwern on Monday September 29, 2014 @02:37PM
(#8384374)
The circumstances which prompted the formation of IRBs would not have been solved by IRBs: IRBs would not have stopped the military from harming downwinders, would not have stopped Nazis, etc. That's all one needs to know.
Having gone through some IRBs, there is a good reason and enough historic precedent to warrant this "long rigamarole". The point is that you can't simply say "but everyone on the Internet does it" and expect people who support traditional research ethics not to say "wait a minute, that shouldn't make it OK".