News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the Facebook Experiment Is Lousy Social Science by res0nat0r on Sunday September 28, 2014 @02:44PM (#8380564)
You need to be upset about any online company that does A/B testing also then without consent. Does this new button make people happy and want to subscribe to our content vs. our old design? This outrage is overblown and really only exists because it is from Facebook.
Re:Why the Facebook Experiment Is Lousy Social Science by aroch on Sunday September 28, 2014 @02:57PM (#8380603)
A/B testing is not the same thing as manipulating content based on negative/positive connotation and tracking user emotion change as a result. They're conceptually similar but the resulting change in user expression is not. A/B testing is optimizing your site and user interactions with it, Facebook's experiment is trying to change a users interactions with the world.

I would be just as upset if it were Google or my local grocer.

Re:Why the Facebook Experiment Is Lousy Social Science by res0nat0r on Sunday September 28, 2014 @03:13PM (#8380638)
Sure it is. All advertising is manipulating user emotion, and A/B testing different advertising methods / button layouts on your site to improve conversions is one such use.

If this is something that upsets you I suggest being upset at every commercial on the radio / newspaper / tv / billboard that you're unfortunately exposed to every day.

Re:Why the Facebook Experiment Is Lousy Social Science by teaneedz on Sunday September 28, 2014 @10:00PM (#8381421)
At the end of the day, it does boil down to how users feel, but legit A/B seeks better features, improved user-experience, or identifying something better. The tech community, developers and data folks need to understand that all A/B is not equal. If we allow FB (or OKC) to pass off their ill-thought psych experiments as normal A/B or similar day-to-day product testing, we lower the UE bar. It has also been pointed out elsewhere that this particular study was/is illegal, violating certain state laws on Common Rule practice regardless of funding source. I hope that board members and the C-suite take a new leadership role to educate their teams as to what acceptable and legal A/B should look like.
Re:Why the Facebook Experiment Is Lousy Social Science by aroch on Sunday September 28, 2014 @03:22PM (#8380661)
People know ads are trying to manipulate them, they don't know that Facebook is actively trying to make them feel happier or sadder. Just because two things are similar does not make them morally equivalent.

People have been calling out various bad practices in conversion: http://darkpatterns.org/

Re:Why the Facebook Experiment Is Lousy Social Science by res0nat0r on Sunday September 28, 2014 @03:47PM (#8380718)
Emotional manipulation happens every day in all kinds of fields other than advertising, I wouldn't refer to all of these as "dark patterns."
Re:Why the Facebook Experiment Is Lousy Social Science by kaoD on Sunday September 28, 2014 @09:27PM (#8381364)
> Emotional manipulation happens every day in all kinds of fields other than advertising

So it's not bad because everyone else does it?

Re:Why the Facebook Experiment Is Lousy Social Science by thisGuysAccount on Sunday September 28, 2014 @03:14PM (#8380639)
I agree that A/B testing is not the same thing.

A real-world comparison of the two different types of experiments:

Grocer wants to see the effect of a product demo's effect on sales. They have a worker offer a product sample, then recommend a pairing of products vs offering a coupon for that product. A/B testing.

Grocer wants to see the effect of a product's demo on the customer's emotions. He has the demo worker gripe about their boss, or talking positively about the community, then asks the cashiers for followup feedback on the smalltalk at their counters.

One of these is OK. The other is seedy.

Re:Why the Facebook Experiment Is Lousy Social Science by Ar-Curunir on Sunday September 28, 2014 @03:42PM (#8380708)
Sure, but the problem here is that this study blurred academic and corporate boundaries. Studies I've conducted involved telling the participants after the study that they were being recorded. Immediately after.

It is a requirement instituted by the IRB in most universities. That is the problem being mentioned here.

Furthermore, Facebook is a different case from most companies because it is an intrinsically personal website that has the potential to affect a user's life very meaningfully. Amazon changing the design or location of a button doesn't affect me as much.