Re:YouTube Comes To A 5-Star Realization: Its Ratings Are Us...
by netsp on Tuesday September 22, 2009 @08:21PM
(#838319)
Maybe it's because Amazon asks (and receives) written reviews as well. They make people think a little more. I assume there is still a bias towards the 1 & 5 stars though.
Re:YouTube Comes To A 5-Star Realization: Its Ratings Are Us...
by Anon84 on Tuesday September 22, 2009 @09:46PM
(#838450)
Not quite. See http://arxiv.org/pdf/0909.0237 Page 9 Table 4.
The closest I've ever seen to the "ideal" curve is the IMDB curve right next to it.
Re:YouTube Comes To A 5-Star Realization: Its Ratings Are Us...
by netsp on Wednesday September 23, 2009 @12:13AM
(#838585)
I love that on HN you can get as a response to a vague & half-arsed comment a reference and link to an academic paper.
Cheers.
Re:YouTube Comes To A 5-Star Realization: Its Ratings Are Us...
by mynameishere on Wednesday September 23, 2009 @11:08AM
(#839370)
http://74.125.113.132/search?q=cache:QCWrYt03Y8UJ:sloanwordp...
The econometric results reveal that the reviews for the majority of the products have an asymmetric bimodal distribution.
etc. I thought everyone knew this, and it makes sense. You don't review something if you think it's "okay". You review it if you love it or hate it. Rottentomatoes probably has a bell curve because the professional reviewers review everything, whether they want to or not.
Also, the reviews on youtube are quite useful, and a three-or-less star average indicates that something is labeled incorrectly (for copyrighted material, tv shows, movies, videos, and the like).
Then again, Amazon doesn't account for the statistical uncertainty of votes, so it's a little odd as well.