And frankly, that would be a reason for you not to be a manager of Fed regulators.
The Beim report specifically, specifically, says the kind of dissent she represented is exactly what the Fed needs.
And she did offer options, that she could simply be overruled if her superiors disagreed. This is how it should work. If they disagree, they need to personally be taking responsibility for that disagreement, not forcing the employee to change their views.
Not to mention it's pretty clear Goldman had no operative conflict of interest policy. They've simply been in blatant conflict too often for it to be believable there's anything limiting it.
The issue is when she knowingly states as fact something that is not accurate (i.e. there is NO policy). That crosses the line into slander since it can cause reputational and financial harm to the institution being investigated.
Even more importantly, by one regulator giving the appearance of "gunning" for Goldman it jeopardizes the work of countless others who also have findings and research that may actually be true.
I don't see why consensus is such a necessary issue. We don't have consensus in any part of our government, but we are quite happy having dissenting supreme court justices write their own opinions. Why can't regulators also have dissenting opinions? The health of our economy is far more important than anyone's personal feelings in the matter.
Not "unable to compromise or see other viewpoints besides her own." More like unwilling to put down in writing that 2+2==5, just because her boss said so. Or to sit silently and be a party to gross malfeasance (at taxpayer's expense), generally.
But with your own cocky dismissal of her actions, it sounds like you'd do very well at a company like Goldman.
The big showdown on whether Goldman had a conflicts of interest policy came down to a difference of opinion that she was clearly in the wrong on. Her boss's request to amend her statement to say that they had one but it was totally inadequate should have been an easy one to agree to. Especially if the Fed's legal department was the one objecting to saying there was no policy.
Instead she comes across as extremely stubborn and unable to compromise or see other viewpoints besides her own. I would have fired her too just because she was so difficult to work with.
Silva does seem spineless in going out of the way to not verbally offend Goldman, but IMO that is more of a personality trait that him ignoring evidence.
Now she's suing wanting to be vindicated that she was really right all along and everyone else was wrong, and releasing the tapes to support that. Not a Goldman fan, but for this report there is really no moral outrage to be had.