Re:Man receives constant pain signals from his brain
by kyllo on Thursday September 25, 2014 @09:18PM
(#8370800)
First: employer based health care, as weird as it is, serves a role as collective bargaining. Losing the sick person is good. Losing the sick person and a couple thousand healthy people is bad (or at least less good).
Except that many large employers are self-insured anyway, they only have an insurance company contracted to administer claims, but the employer pays.
So, unfortunately the company then has an incentive not to employ sick people and old people.
Re:Man receives constant pain signals from his brain
by dllthomas on Thursday September 25, 2014 @10:46PM
(#8371085)
"Except that many large employers are self-insured anyway"
Many; it's not all, I'm not sure it's most, and the dynamic I spoke of is still present in smaller employers.
"So, unfortunately the company then has an incentive not to employ sick people and old people."
I never claimed employer based coverage was a panacea. I explicitly called it weird, and I specifically said that it doesn't entirely fix the issue.
Right, with two caveats. A big problem with relying on competition to get good behaviour out of health insurers is that for health care in particular the common pattern is that expenses are low, and then for some expenses get high and stay high. As you say, this means that as soon as you need to actually use your insurance, you're a "problem customer" and - basic incentives wise - they'd rather not have you as a customer any more. If they frustrate you sufficiently that you say, "Screw this, I'm going to your competitor!" they win - they keep all the money you paid in, and it's their competitor that needs to pay out now.
The caveats.
First: employer based health care, as weird as it is, serves a role as collective bargaining. Losing the sick person is good. Losing the sick person and a couple thousand healthy people is bad (or at least less good).
The other caveat is the cap on the medical loss ratio in the ACA. If a company is operating near the cap (and why wouldn't they be?) then the pool of money available for executives and shareholders can depend more on total revenues than on revenues minus medical costs. When that's true, losing any customer hurts - even one that nets negative.
I don't think either of these is doing enough (the second might, long term, but I'm not sure the industry has internalized it yet), but they help some.