Re:Billionaire must let public access Martins Beach, judge r...
by michaelt on Thursday September 25, 2014 @07:18AM
(#8366571)
What he probably wanted was to prevent [...] founders
'accidentally' meeting him when he was at home, and so on.
If a guy buys a house next door to a fire station, and he's woken up by fire engine sirens, I feel a bit bad for him. But he knew when he brought the house there was a fire station opposite.I think the same thing about Khosla's beach access - I feel bad if he's having problems, but he knew the beach access was there when he brought the property.
There is a thing called the 'principle of double effect' (thought up by Thomas Aquinas back in the 13th century; it's not a new thing) that's incredibly important to understanding the world around us - nothing we do has a single, isolated effect. Ever. There are always several causes for things, and many effects. Picking one and assuming that was the reason, or even just the most important reason, is wrong. In this case it's reasonable to think Khosla closed access to the beach for several reasons, and that had several effects, one of which was preventing public access which is why it ended up in court.