News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook and OkCupid Broke the Law When They Experimented... by dragonwriter on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @05:58PM (#8358590)
> My problem is, I'm not sure what MD 917 (b) means.

Probably Annotated Code of Maryland Section 13-1601(b), added by House Bill 917, means exactly what it says. "Notwithstanding any provision in the federal regulations on the protection of human subjects that limits the applicability of the federal regulations to certain research, subsection (a) of this section applies to all research using a human subject." (emphasis added)

> §46.102 (b) has a list of human research which is exempt.

But those exemptions are a provision of the federal regulations which limits the applicability of the federal regulation to certain research, and so are expressly excluded from the part of the regulation incorporated into Maryland law by Section 13-1601(b).

> Otherwise - and this is another tricky part - §46.102 (c) says "Department or agency heads retain final judgment as to whether a particular activity is covered by this policy."

This, again, is a provision of the federal regulations which limits the applicability of the federal regulation to certain research (to those things not excluded by the relevant funding department/agency head), and so are expressly excluded from the part of the regulation incorporated into Maryland law by 917(b). So there's no need to figure out how it applies -- it doesn't.

> However, if that's the case then the other exceptions of §46.102 (b) are also no longer allowed

Note that, if you go through the link you posted and click on the final passed (Third Reading) version of the bill and note the edits from the prior version, that prior version of the bill had express language incorporating the exceptions in 45 CFR § 46.102(b) as exceptions to the Maryland law, and this was stricken in favor of the language now present expressly disregarding any exceptions in the federal regulations. This makes it pretty clear that, whether or not this is desirable, the legislative intent was very expressly not to incorporate the exceptions in 45 CFR § 46.102(b).

Re:Facebook and OkCupid Broke the Law When They Experimented... by dalke on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @06:27PM (#8358745)
I suspect my edit was too late for you to read. I added a link to http://www.oag.state.md.us/Healthpol/hb917letter.pdf , where the attorney general describes exemptions:

> Therefore, under the applicable federal regulations, a person may conduct research in an exempt category without, for example, obtaining review by an institutional review board. A Maryland researcher likewise may do so under House Bill 917, because such a person is conducting the research “in accordance with the federal regulations on the protection of human subjects” and, consequently, does not violate the prohibition in § 13-1602(a) of the Health-General Article.

This is dated May 2, which is after the bill passed both houses and before it was signed by the governor.

This seems like the exemptions in §46.102 (b) are all allowed under MD law.

Re:Facebook and OkCupid Broke the Law When They Experimented... by dragonwriter on Tuesday September 23, 2014 @07:39PM (#8359028)
There seems to me, on the surface, to be some very odd statutory construction underlying that analysis (which is presented in a much less full form than a typical opinion letter, because that's not really what this is, so its really hard to form much of an opinion of its conclusion) -- but certainly it at least indicates how the legal authorities of the State may be likely to apply the law, presuming that their construction of the statute hasn't changed in the intervening decade.