Is that really a line of reasoning? I can make money by drug and arms trafficking, helping other skirt the law, take advantage of legal loopholes, using violence where competitors cannot to strongarm others into submission, exploiting labor, etc.
If a hedge fund makes its money just by being faster in transactions in a way that gives no real benefit to actual creators of value, then it is of no use to society.
Thus far, the argument for liquidity seems shoddy, at best.
Real estate firms exist to make money using real estate. Banks exist to make money using loans.
Finance exists to make money. By design, it doesn't care about real value.
By and large you can't, which is the point. We don't stop these things by appealing to people's better natures. We stop these things by making them unprofitable. When hedge funds misbehave it's usually a symptom, not a cause.
If it's useless then why does it make them money? Capitalism is a bit like a genetic algorithm - it will find a badly specified reward function faster than it will find the solution you were looking for - but if our tax policies encourage businesses to take on dangerous levels of debt, maybe we should, like, change our tax policies?
> So - to deliver middling average returns, the hedge fund industry will charge 4x to 20x the cost of an index fund.
Shouldn't we be happy about that? They take a load of rich people's money, provide liquidity to the market and do other price discovery things, and give those rich people a middling average return. What's not to like?
> Much of the money for the funds comes from public pension funds.
Maybe those pension funds should stop investing in hedge funds, like calpers just did.