News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Are there startups that went open-source and succ... by kazinator on Friday September 19, 2014 @04:31PM (#8342341)
That's just the definition of "open source" by some people who have an agenda and want to hijack the language for their own use; I will buy it when it appears in the same form in Merriam-Webster or Oxford. Until then, "open source" is purely a compositional compound noun in the English language that is understood by combining the meanings of "open" and "source". Open doesn't say anything about non-proprietary. If you're taking an "open book exam", that doesn't mean that the book comes with a license that allows unlimited photocopying for all your friends. If you "open up" to someone, you aren't publicizing your life to the whole world. If all the users of a program have the source code, or easy access to it, that source is open. If he program is proprietary, then perhaps some of those who have the source code are unlicensed users. They still have the source code, and it is still effectively "open source" to them too.

And in the context of some programming language that has no binary code, would you even continue to use the term "open source" and "closed source"? Could some uncompiled, unobfuscated script that is sold to users under a license that prohibits redistribution be called "closed source", when it is delivered in properly indented, well-commented code with meaningful identifiers?

Richard Stallman builds a good case for avoiding the term "open source" when referring to free software.

http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point.h...

Hey look, like me, he recognizes the "obvious meaning" of the term:

RMS> "Since the obvious meaning for “open source” is not the meaning that its advocates intend, the result is that most people misunderstand the term."

I don't agree with Stallman on this point, though: those people are English speakers who understand the term. They just don't understand how those advocates are using it, which is their fault: they are not communicating effectively.

RMS> "Open source supporters try to deal with this by pointing to their official definition, but that corrective approach is less effective for them than it is for us [advocates of 'free software']."

Re:Ask HN: Are there startups that went open-source and succ... by dllthomas on Friday September 19, 2014 @04:43PM (#8342388)
This is inane. I wasn't making any claim to a "true" definition; just pointing out that it is manifestly the case that using it that way is going to confuse a lot of people - including, I think, most programmers. If you intend to reclaim the term , it's best to explicitly make plain that you are doing so.

Edited to add:

And, as it happens:

http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/open-source

"of software : having the source code freely available for possible modification and redistribution"

http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/us/definition/american_eng...

"Denoting software for which the original source code is made freely available and may be redistributed and modified."

Note that both of these include that redistribution is permitted. So, um, buy it.

Re:Ask HN: Are there startups that went open-source and succ... by kazinator on Friday September 19, 2014 @04:49PM (#8342417)
Bought.

They adopted that surprisingly fast!

Interestingly, both dictionaries recommend that it be hyphenated as open-source.

Re:Ask HN: Are there startups that went open-source and succ... by dllthomas on Friday September 19, 2014 @04:55PM (#8342445)
"They adopted that surprisingly fast!"

Heh, it's been around much longer than "tweet" (in the sense of posting two twitter) or "sexting", which have both apparently made it in.