News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Are there startups that went open-source and succ... by bane on Friday September 19, 2014 @02:39PM (#8341839)
Define "succeed".

Anecdote time. The last open source company I dealt with worked in the big data space. They messaged themselves as a product company and listed 3 products on their page.

I was working for a company providing client tools and we were teamed together by a larger System Integrator on a contract proposal.

While working with them I got curious about their product (hey, maybe someplace cool to go work someday).

The conversation went something like this:

   Me: So you guys have some impressive software, you must have a heck of a dev shop

   Them: We do. The good news is that we got a nice head start using some open source stuff, hadoop, etc.

   Me: Oh. So what bits did you guys make?

   Them: Well we made this (points to web accessible management console) and did the glue work to pull together the open source bits

   Me: Oh. So is your value proposition then that you guys have tightly integrated this technology stack and...

   Them: *Right* and provide the technical expertise to run it. (sits up proudly) and all the work *we* did has been open sourced as well (goes to their github page).

   Me: so....if I were a customer and I bought x amount of product A from you, what exactly am I getting?

   Them: you're getting the integrated stack and our expertise and support.

   Me: Support available by contract?

   Them: Right.

   Me: So let's say I'm the customer...what's to prevent me from just downloading and compiling all the source code for your stack and your glue and just poaching a couple of your guys and saving myself a few million dollars in FTE hours?

   Them:Well that's highly unethical...poaching our people

   Me:okay, or I find a couple really good guys on most of this stack and give them 3 or 4 months to come to grips with it and your glue...same thing...what's your guys' value proposition to go with your company instead of just doing that?

   Them:...

They sold to another company a few months later and I've heard it was mostly for the customer contracts they already had in place. I'm not aware they were ever profitable or on a path to profit. Great success?

My point is, you have to really consider this kind of line-of-questioning and put together a rock solid value proposition to have a chance at succeeding. Because why pay you for whatever when I can get it free as in beer and use my own people who I'm already paying for?

There are no comments on this comment yet.