Re:France ditches the name ISIS, replacing it with a label t...
by zo1 on Thursday September 18, 2014 @02:48PM
(#8336913)
"The public is already aware of who "ISIS" is, and what they do."
The majority of people do, yes. However, you have to consider how powerful language is. Calling something by it's literal, and true meaning strips it of a lot of power to maneuver itself and what it means/stands for.
Re:France ditches the name ISIS, replacing it with a label t...
by colanderman on Thursday September 18, 2014 @01:23PM
(#8336429)
Well, seeing as this is the French who are using the term, I don't think you have to worry about pronouncing it.
Re:France ditches the name ISIS, replacing it with a label t...
by Crito on Thursday September 18, 2014 @01:44PM
(#8336561)
Every argument in favor of the new term, that I have heard at least, is language agnostic. They apply in English just as well as they apply in French. I think it is therefore fair for me to offer my opinion on its use by English speaking media.
And yeah, my insincere proposal got somewhat neutered by a few iterations of making it less offensive to the innocent. I think my point came across though.
Re:France ditches the name ISIS, replacing it with a label t...
by colanderman on Thursday September 18, 2014 @08:26PM
(#8338425)
Your "point" is a straw-man.
(Really, that name is ridiculous. "Daesh" is specifically chosen because it's already used. I'm not arguing to call them something novel and ridiculous.)
Re:France ditches the name ISIS, replacing it with a label t...
by Crito on Friday September 19, 2014 @10:53PM
(#8343531)
1) One of the arguments in favour of using that term is that it offends ISIS. It's not a strawman if people actually are making that argument. I am arguing against that particular argument.
2) Daesh is not already used in English. I have absolutely no objection to it's use in other languages; that does not effect me in the slightest so I could not care in the slightest.
The public is already aware of who "ISIS" is, and what they do. I see no reason to introduce confusion (particularly with a word whose pronunciation isn't even clear to all native English speakers (such as myself)).