Re:Richmond Italian restaurant waging war on Yelp
by tim333 on Thursday September 18, 2014 @10:16AM
(#8335300)
At least on Amazon you can see the misleading reviews quite easily - just click to view the one stars and see if they are relevant or not. Personally I find Amazon reviews about the best in terms of actually deciding what stuff to buy.
Re:Richmond Italian restaurant waging war on Yelp
by RunningWild on Thursday September 18, 2014 @11:37AM
(#8335787)
This doesn't mirror my own experience. Typically the 5-star reviews often fall into the category "worked great for me" or fanboyism, but it's generally ambiguous how extensive of a test they've performed on the item, if it even warrants it (though some reviews are exhaustive on this front). And 1-star reviews often are hyper-critical to excess, though any potential issues are often highlighted there, prompting me to read them first. Since all reviews end up with these extremes and the "is this review helpful" ironically isn't often helpful (more like, "do I agree with the review"), I always end up just going with my initial gut feeling on whatever I'm looking to buy anyways.
Re:Richmond Italian restaurant waging war on Yelp
by blisterpeanuts on Thursday September 18, 2014 @09:52AM
(#8335179)
Amazon does provide a "verified purchaser" indicator.
Also, in all these review sites - how do we know if the reviewer actually used the product/service? Amazon seems to differentiate, but what about others?
It would be awesome to have a review site where 1. All reviews older than 6 months (or 1 year or whatever timeframe makes sense) are not shown by default 2. Only confirmed users of the product/service are able to review