Re:Richmond Italian restaurant waging war on Yelp
by maroonblazer on Thursday September 18, 2014 @09:32AM
(#8335063)
The problem with Amazon's system is that unless you know to look to see if the review is helpful, you may think it legit.
StackExchange solved this problem. I don't know why more sites use that approach to reviews.
Re:Richmond Italian restaurant waging war on Yelp
by kps on Thursday September 18, 2014 @10:31AM
(#8335370)
The best part of Amazon's review system is the graph. Normal near the top, fine. Bimodal (controversial books excepted) is a red flag.
Re:Richmond Italian restaurant waging war on Yelp
by svantana on Thursday September 18, 2014 @09:26AM
(#8335033)
Combine that with a karma system à la HN and you should have something...
Re:Richmond Italian restaurant waging war on Yelp
by misaelm on Thursday September 18, 2014 @09:24AM
(#8335027)
I don't know how it works for Amazon, but my guess is that only for the products that get a lot of traffic (e.g. kindle) you have enough "honest" opinions to get rid of the bias.
Re:Richmond Italian restaurant waging war on Yelp
by eevilspock on Thursday September 18, 2014 @09:33AM
(#8335074)
Yes, that's part of the solution. But it has to be much more robust than "This review was useful". The meta-moderation needs to be recusive, e.g. like PageRank.
The other part of the solution is a review system designed around the fact that people have different tastes. Netflix at least tries to do that. On Yelp, a great hole-in-the-wall will average three stars because those that don't like them will vote the opposite of those that love them. Three stars doesn't help either type of person.
i.e. "was this review useful?" gets "no" for both the above reviews.
Seems to work IMO.