Re:Pants: Build system by Twitter, Foursquare, and Square
by harryh on Wednesday September 17, 2014 @10:06PM
(#8333280)
shrug Haven't messed with redo or tup. Maybe they do great dependency tracking as well. It's not a new idea. Pants is basically a copy of Google's build system by a bunch of ex-Googlers.
Pants also does nifty things like artifact caching between members of a team which is nice.
It will continue to do more nice things in the future as it's under active development by a decent number of people at this point.
Re:Pants: Build system by Twitter, Foursquare, and Square
by beagle3 on Thursday September 18, 2014 @01:59AM
(#8333934)
tup does perfect instantaneous dependency tracking: It monitors file system access to see which files were accessed during build (you don't have to tell it). It does not depend on tool co-operation, and it's the only build system that will figure out that you've upgraded your compiler (e.g. if javac or gcc was replaced) and thus a rebuild is in order.
redo is explicit; it doesn't automatically do dependency tracking, you have to tell it what went it. But it's fast and incredibly elegant - it's extremely easy to make it track any dependencies you know about, and it's built for easily rebuilding just a part of your system.
[0] http://apenwarr.ca/log/?m=201012#14 - designed by djb, implemented by apenwarr.
[1] http://gittup.org/tup/ - the fastest build system you'll ever meet, with an essentially perfect automatic dependency tracker