Re:Ask HN: What do you think of my new site?
by zemaj on Sunday September 20, 2009 @07:34AM
(#832978)
Also some of your buttons perform JavaScript operations, some load new pages - with the same design and sitting next to each other. It's always best to be consistent and have some sort of icon or UI element to define which actions keep you on the same page.
I agree that email validation is flawed in terms of ensuring uniqueness, so this is something I may drop and insist users create an account. One thing I have considered in the mean time is allowing registered users to hide non-signed in participants.
Re:Ask HN: What do you think of my new site?
by m_eiman on Sunday September 20, 2009 @07:58AM
(#832996)
That'd be better. Make the default action when voting "vote as anonymous, unless logged in", and upgrade that anonymous vote to a registered one if the user decides to register after voting.
Also, having an account is not ensuring uniqueness either.
Also say that the email address requires validation. I put in a fake address and of-course my vote didn't get counted. If I knew up-front it was to be validated I probably would have entered a correct one.
Having said all that I don't agree with email validation. It doesn't ensure unique votes. Can you explain why you choose it?