Re:Mars and Moon Are Out of NASA's Reach for Now, Review Pan...
by fjabre on Sunday September 20, 2009 @03:27AM
(#832855)
Excellent. Wish I had more time to respond to this but point well made.
With enough supplies I believe Mars is habitable. There just wouldnt be a return mission.
I agree with you about the money. We cant afford it right now.
Too bad... I'd much rather be tooling around in space than fighting a war in Iraq...
Re:Mars and Moon Are Out of NASA's Reach for Now, Review Pan...
by DanielBMarkham on Sunday September 20, 2009 @03:42AM
(#832862)
Stross' blog entry is interesting. It's good to have somebody like him lay out the math in regards to space exploration and colonization.
I agree -- the only smart thing to do is to advance research into things that lower the cost. If you asked somebody from 1850 what it would take to visit the moon, you'd get a response much like Stross': it's simply a matter of technology.
I believe that field propulsion will eventually be invented and will save the day for a lot of these issues, but I base that completely on faith in technological progress.
I'm not at all sure that we have the means to make the Earth less habitable than the Moon or Mars. The Moon is pretty darned uninhabitable. Mars likewise.
Assuming the absolute worst of the nuclear winter hypotheses to be true, we could perhaps destroy most of the higher life on Earth. But even after a nuclear winter the Earth would still have substantial amounts of water and oxygen, and almost certainly a functioning biosphere of some sort. [1] Which is more than can be said for the Moon or even Mars.
Meanwhile, we most certainly don't have the technology to reach an extrasolar Earth-like planet, and spending tens of billions of dollars to have humans dork around in near-solar orbit won't change that fact one bit. If you really do dream of settling other planets, you need to spend far fewer dollars on far more radical experiments. Or you need to read Charles Stross:
http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2007/06/the_high...
Possibly both.
--
[1] Bacteria are hard to kill. Many of them thrive on the lightless ocean floor at extremely high temperatures. And unicellular creatures built our oxygen atmosphere, so the loss of it probably won't bother them too much.