In addition Product Hunt is also focused on email, which is a relatively easy to monetize medium. The job board, podcast, and the data they're collecting has additional potential.
Once you take into account that investment money is plentiful and valuations are a back-of-the-envelope practice anyway then backing this YC startup is a financial no-brainer.
So, duh, they're obviously gonna try to expand it to consumer verticals. Where it winds up being Pinterest with a Reddit/YC upvote/downvote UI. Not worth $7M total in funding imho.
And guess what. Consumers don't do deal flow. VCs and angels NEED a river of announcements all day long, and a way to gauge interest from others (that's the lemming DNA talking).
Even if they end up pivoting in a consumer/pinterest direction (my guess is they won't) they can do very well. Reddit is valued at $500 million and pinterest at 10 times that, after all.
I think that people tend to get really hung up on the dollar amounts involved here. Millions of dollars for something that's little more than a proof of concept seems like a lot. But it's not that much money in the big picture. Businesses and gov't squander millions of dollars on pilot projects all the time (but behind closed doors). As long as a couple of those projects make it big the economics of it still work out.
It's a shit load of money that tons of companies would kill for.
You are living in a fantasy land.
120,000 * 30 * 4 = $14.4M
Even at 60k total cost you break 6M in 4 years:
60,000 * 30 * 4 = $7.2M
> It's big for the average series A for YC
That's not true, it would be huge for a Seed, but that's a fairly middle of the road series A. Big would be in the 10M+ range.
When you consider the highly concentrated audience of product development users of the site, the valuation makes sense.