News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by dfranke on Friday September 18, 2009 @08:45PM (#831461)
We’re offering a free TechCrunch tshirt to any Google employee that forwards that screenshot to us. No questions asked.

Anyone left on HN who still wants to stand up for Arrington's reputation as a journalist?

Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by ksvs on Friday September 18, 2009 @09:01PM (#831480)
There are few reporters who wouldn't accept leaked documents. Some of the most famous news stories were based on leaks.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by dfranke on Friday September 18, 2009 @09:07PM (#831487)
There are hopefully considerably fewer offering explicit quid pro quos for said documents.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by davidw on Saturday September 19, 2009 @04:32AM (#831793)
I will see the shirt offer and raise him one shirt. Any Google employee who forwards me confidential and highly important legal documents, and thus risking immediate firing if not a lawsuit of their own, will get not one, but two t-shirts! All the way from Italy!

Sheez...

Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by raquo on Saturday September 19, 2009 @08:52AM (#831918)
Free startup idea: T-shirt funding pool for leaked documents.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by mikedouglas on Friday September 18, 2009 @09:12PM (#831491)
Putting aside that we're talking about a shirt, what is unethical about buying leaked information, as long as it is legitimate news?
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by dfranke on Friday September 18, 2009 @09:18PM (#831497)
It's not legitimate news. It's confidential correspondence. Arrington is seeking to bribe a Google employee to betray his employer by breaching his NDA. If the document were evidence of wrongdoing on Google's part, it would be a different matter -- the employee would be a whistleblower and his betrayal would be laudable. But that's not what we're talking about. Google is the victim of the alleged wrongdoing. If the information gets leaked, they're victimized even further by being deprived of a bargaining chip with Apple.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by mikedouglas on Friday September 18, 2009 @09:45PM (#831527)
It's not legitimate news.

Apple lied in an official FCC inquiry. That's news.

Arrington is seeking to bribe a Google employee to betray his employer by breaching his NDA.

The vast majority of news leaks throughout history have been based on ulterior motives; whether they are politically or financially-based, seems inconsequential. TechCrunch isn't a party to that NDA, so they should only consider the public interest of the story.

If the information gets leaked, they're victimized even further by being deprived of a bargaining chip with Apple.

What bargaining chip? The ability to collude to scuttle a government investigation? If the FCC asks for the letter, Google has to give it up anyways.

Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by GHFigs on Saturday September 19, 2009 @09:42AM (#831960)
Apple lied in an official FCC inquiry.

Can someone point out the lie to me?

Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by vermontdevil on Saturday September 19, 2009 @10:02AM (#831970)
Mike Arrington said so.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by ErrantX on Saturday September 19, 2009 @04:38AM (#831796)
Your kind of assuming that Google would want the FCC investigation to conclude and effectively force Apple into accepting Voice.

But perhaps they would prefer for Apple to just get so uncomfortable over the poking around they accept Voice off bat in an attempt to take the heat off.

Which means Google have that rejection letter as big guns at any later stage.

Yes Google have to give it to the FCC if they ask for it - but if they don't ask (I am not 100% sure of the rules here) they don't have to mention it or do more than vaguely hint at it's existence.

Right?

Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by pmorici on Friday September 18, 2009 @09:33PM (#831514)
Lock up your secrets their giving away t-shirts. What employee is going to risk their career for a t-shirt.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by skolor on Friday September 18, 2009 @09:18PM (#831498)
More than that, I was wondering: Who would do that for a T-Shirt? Its just disgusting to me (and indicative of why I don't read Tech Crunch) that they are so full of themselves that they feel even a T-Shirt from them holds significant value.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by jkincaid on Friday September 18, 2009 @09:41PM (#831523)
We don't, it's a joke. I am having a hard time believing so many people on this site didn't catch that.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by tvon on Friday September 18, 2009 @10:34PM (#831574)
It fits nicely with our expectations.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by electromagnetic on Friday September 18, 2009 @10:04PM (#831548)
Agreed, perhaps the work week has sapped people of their sense of humour. Or perhaps there's a rare genetic anomaly that turns people into hackers and leaves them without a single funny-bone in their body.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by skolor on Friday September 18, 2009 @10:22PM (#831562)
Its not that its a lost sense of humour, I would guess (because I know why I thought it wasn't a joke) its because of the relatively low opinion many people here have of TechCrunch. Its almost (at least to me) like Nixon, right after Watergate, joking "I wouldn't want you to get a parking ticket..." Sure, it isn't a big deal, but it is rather slimy, and since you already have a low opinion of the party, the whole "joke" is skipped over.

And the fact that sarcasm doesn't translate over the internet well doesn't help any. Or, as I have refered to it: damn you internet and your lack of signifying sarcasm, or, in the semi-pronouncable internet acronym form: DYIAYLOSS.

Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by electromagnetic on Friday September 18, 2009 @10:55PM (#831589)
I don't believe this would have gone over much better if spoken aloud. Sarcasm isn't typically a humour well used in NA, either people can't say it right or people don't understand it. Coming from the UK where sarcasm can be used in every sentence, it's like being the only person with sight in a world of blind people.

I believe (!) should become a standard for sarcasm on the web, it would at least hint people that the line is different from the norm.

Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by dasil003 on Saturday September 19, 2009 @01:15PM (#832147)
Glad you mentioned the UK or I would have no idea what the hell you meant by NA.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by nostrademons on Saturday September 19, 2009 @01:21AM (#831679)
Lessee...Google job, T-shirt. I think I'd rather have the job.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by jkincaid on Friday September 18, 2009 @09:40PM (#831520)
It's a joke. Up to you whether you think it's funny or not, but as grounds to question his credibility? Lighten up.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by zaidf on Saturday September 19, 2009 @01:58AM (#831706)
I once passed on a story to TC that had one upvote on HN at the time. It went on to become a huge sensation online and in print worldwide. I won't disclose it but basically the company threatened to sue all involved in spreading it. Afraid, I wrote to Arrington and he assured me he'd rather goto jail than out a source.

Of course I never seriously thought the company had a case(especially against me). I just took a public link and fwded it to someone who made it big. Very different from leaking.

Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by Nwallins on Saturday September 19, 2009 @12:02PM (#832071)
> I once passed on a story to TC that had one upvote on HN

The meaning of this is completely changed if you parse it like:

I once passed on a story...

Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by logic on Friday September 18, 2009 @08:49PM (#831466)
I expected the TechCrunch readership to not get a little jab of humor, but here too?
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by dfranke on Friday September 18, 2009 @08:58PM (#831473)
It isn't funny. Arrington seems to think it is, but apparently all he's laughing at is his own lack of ethics rather than at any intended jest:

i mean, sure, we’d take the docs and deliver the tshirt. but we do have one or two other ways of getting information.

Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by idm on Friday September 18, 2009 @09:15PM (#831494)
I'm in the "t-shirt was a joke" camp, but this does cause me to wonder: is this alleged screenshot also a joke?

I mean, in the context of the t-shirt thing, just how credible can Arrington's screenshot claim be, anyway?

Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by bmelton on Friday September 18, 2009 @09:22PM (#831501)
What strikes me as worrisome is that, at least by the tone of the article, there is no possible doubt in Arrington's mind that the screenshot exists, and that it is EXACTLY what was claimed to him, and he hasn't even seen it.

I'm sure it's a somewhat thin argument, but I personally would think they'd start reserving their over-committal in the wake of the Facebook-picture-fax thing. I mean, they bought that hook, line and sinker, and that was a hoax they at least SAW.

Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by mikedouglas on Friday September 18, 2009 @09:57PM (#831544)
What strikes me as worrisome is that, at least by the tone of the article, there is no possible doubt in Arrington's mind that the screenshot exists, and that it is EXACTLY what was claimed to him, and he hasn't even seen it.

This is a far better critique of TechCrunch than the "quid pro quo" angle.

Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by dfranke on Friday September 18, 2009 @10:21PM (#831561)
Yes, it is indeed a better critique. That should have occurred to me.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by mullr on Friday September 18, 2009 @08:50PM (#831470)
I find that a little funny. By wearing the free t-shirt, wouldn't everybody know what it's you that leaked said screenshot? Unless everybody at google regularly wears techcrunch clothing, which probably isn't likely. He should probably offer something which doesn't implicitly identify his source.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by idm on Friday September 18, 2009 @09:17PM (#831496)
I hope the shirt says, "I leaked evidence in my employer's multi-million-dollar lawsuit and all I got was this lousy t-shirt"
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by GHFigs on Saturday September 19, 2009 @10:19AM (#831984)
What lawsuit?
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by pjvandehaar on Friday September 18, 2009 @09:30PM (#831510)
This is disproved by the fact that at least 10 perfectly photoshopped screenshots had to have been submitted in the first hour, and have not been posted.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by josefresco on Saturday September 19, 2009 @08:55AM (#831922)
Anyone HN left with a sense of humor? dranke apparently lost his.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by erlanger on Friday September 18, 2009 @09:08PM (#831488)
I don't see a problem with this.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by tlrobinson on Saturday September 19, 2009 @07:22AM (#831876)
The only problem I see is it will be trivial to find the culprit, just look for the Googler wearing a TC shirt.
Re:Google Releases A Nuke. Apple Won’t Win This Fight. by euccastro on Saturday September 19, 2009 @08:42AM (#831909)
He'd wear it inside out.