News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Comcast Declares War on Tor? by naner on Saturday September 13, 2014 @07:01PM (#8313927)
I can't believe I'm "defending" Comcast, but this sounds made-up.

Why would Comcast care about Tor and if they wanted to discourage use why would they confront customers using it?

Re:Comcast Declares War on Tor? by fabulist on Saturday September 13, 2014 @07:44PM (#8314044)
I think the methods are crude but the motives are quite clear (if the story is true); Comcast doesn't like Tor for the same reason the NSA doesn't like Tor. Comcast doesn't have a good track record for handling traffic ethically, for instance attempting to monetize NXDOMAIN errors [1], throttling protocols they don't like [2], etc.

I don't think its beyond the pail to suggest they want to spy on their customers and sell their data to advertisers. They may even be under contractual obligation from RIAA/MPAA to disallow Tor as a part of Six Strikes, and are doing this either before or in lieu of a technical solution.

[1] http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2009/08/comcasts-dns-redi... [2] http://torrentfreak.com/comcast-throttles-bittorrent-traffic...

Re:Comcast Declares War on Tor? by dmix on Saturday September 13, 2014 @07:49PM (#8314056)
Even if money was the motivation its not like Tor is super popular. I doubt it's hurting any ISPs bottom line. My bet this is simply a political move, or one influenced by interested 3rd parties who do financially benefit from a destruction of privacy. Assuming it is real.
Re:Comcast Declares War on Tor? by sroerick on Saturday September 13, 2014 @08:07PM (#8314109)
fabulist is not arguing that this policy is a result of financial loss, but rather contractual obligation with RIAA/MPAA.
Re:Comcast Declares War on Tor? by smtddr on Saturday September 13, 2014 @07:50PM (#8314060)
Totally with you; this story sounds made-up.

>>Users who try to use anonymity, or cover themselves up on the internet, are usually doing things that aren’t so-to-speak legal.

So what does Comcast think about people who use VPN? Maybe VPN also illegal now? Privacy is dead? Next up, curtains on the windows of your house are also illegal.

Re:Comcast Declares War on Tor? by StephenFalken on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:10PM (#8314305)
It's interesting to read what BBC thinks about that [1].

[1] http://torrentfreak.com/bbc-isps-should-assume-heavy-vpn-use...

Re:Comcast Declares War on Tor? by smtddr on Sunday September 14, 2014 @01:36PM (#8315721)
So it's really going to happen... slowly, in the name of piracy(but we know that's not really why), any form of encrypted communication will become illegal. Oh, and of course this won't apply to affluent.
Re:Comcast Declares War on Tor? by dmix on Saturday September 13, 2014 @07:53PM (#8314070)
Or 3rd-party DNS.
Re:Comcast Declares War on Tor? by smtddr on Saturday September 13, 2014 @08:04PM (#8314096)
well, it's possible for Comcast to inspect the hostname of a DNS query even if its destination is not Comcast's nameservers.
Re:Comcast Declares War on Tor? by dmix on Sunday September 14, 2014 @02:45PM (#8315885)
Not if the communication with the DNS server is encrypted, for example with this service: http://www.goldenfrog.com/vyprvpn/features/vyprdns
Re:Comcast Declares War on Tor? by Zuider on Monday September 15, 2014 @02:15PM (#8320414)
Don't even need to use a VPN. DNSCrypt encrypts DNS queries.

http://dnscrypt.org/

Re:Comcast Declares War on Tor? by meowface on Saturday September 13, 2014 @07:05PM (#8313946)
Agreed, this doesn't sound like anything an ISP would actually do.

Comcast isn't run by the brightest people though so I'd be interested to see if anyone provides evidence that these phone calls actually took place.

Re:Comcast Declares War on Tor? by pyre on Saturday September 13, 2014 @07:25PM (#8313999)
Maybe it goes something like this:

1. Customer got caught X time(s) under the "Six Strikes" policy.

2. Comcast starts monitoring customer more closely.

3. Customer starts torrenting over Tor.

4. Comcast (who is monitoring this person more closely) sees that large amounts of traffic is going over Tor.

5. Comcast tries to intimidate customer to stop using Tor.

6. ???

7. Profit?

I'm kind of iffy on the motivation for anything past #4 though, but it seems sort of plausible... maybe?

Re:Comcast Declares War on Tor? by MichaelGG on Saturday September 13, 2014 @09:53PM (#8314277)
If it's not a fabrication, it's more likely the customer was running a Tor exit node and that caused some problems and Comcast told him not to run an exit node. Which is somewhat reasonable, as it's a pain to deal with abuse complaints.
Re:Comcast Declares War on Tor? by cjbprime on Saturday September 13, 2014 @07:02PM (#8313933)
Good point -- it would be very easy for Comcast to disable entries on to the Tor network if they wanted to (as China does), since their IP addresses are public.
Re:Comcast Declares War on Tor? by privong on Saturday September 13, 2014 @07:26PM (#8314000)
To be fair, not all tor IP addresses are public; there are bridge relays which are not publicly listed[0]. This is one of the tactics for getting around blocking of tor in countries such as China.

[0] https://www.torproject.org/docs/bridges.html.en