Re:Trying to Hit the Brake on Texting While Driving
by e40 on Saturday September 13, 2014 @06:35PM
(#8313848)
Why is it the responsibility or even the right of carriers to deny people the service they pay for simply because it annoys you?
Exactly!! Are we so immature that we can't take responsibility for our own behavior and want laws and systems to do for us what we should do for ourselves?
Re:Trying to Hit the Brake on Texting While Driving
by rayiner on Saturday September 13, 2014 @06:48PM
(#8313886)
Because a sufficiently large percentage of the population is shitbags.
Re:Trying to Hit the Brake on Texting While Driving
by RichardFord on Saturday September 13, 2014 @07:55PM
(#8314078)
Yeah, it's always the other guy that needs strict parenting from the government right?
Re:Trying to Hit the Brake on Texting While Driving
by rayiner on Saturday September 13, 2014 @08:30PM
(#8314168)
The majority of people who just want to live safe, comfortable, predictable lives have a right to use government to protect themselves from the (very substantial) minority of people who are shitbags.
Re:Trying to Hit the Brake on Texting While Driving
by RichardFord on Saturday September 13, 2014 @08:56PM
(#8314203)
Predictable? There's autocratic regimes out there where life is much more predictable. We probably more laws to keep government and other autocratic shitbags in check.
Re:Trying to Hit the Brake on Texting While Driving
by rayiner on Saturday September 13, 2014 @11:04PM
(#8314392)
Yes, predictability is something normal people value, and are entitled to structure their society to encourage.
Re:Trying to Hit the Brake on Texting While Driving
by thisGuysAccount on Saturday September 13, 2014 @08:26PM
(#8314153)
Doesn't really need to be "strict" in this case. Texts could come back with a context from the recipient. Say you text someone, they're driving, you get a status of "In motion," or "In a movie," or something based on the data coming back from the phone.
They're not necessarily unable to respond to you, as in not locked out of their phone by the carrier, but the carrier knows they're moving at 30+mph, and gives that data to the sender.
Re:Trying to Hit the Brake on Texting While Driving
by yzzxy on Saturday September 13, 2014 @07:15PM
(#8313972)
When I say smart, I mean purely from a cold, heartless, moneymaking perspective. I would not start this business because I agree with you in many cases.
Re:Trying to Hit the Brake on Texting While Driving
by rayiner on Saturday September 13, 2014 @06:47PM
(#8313882)
Because bars and restaurants are private property?
Re:Trying to Hit the Brake on Texting While Driving
by icebraining on Saturday September 13, 2014 @06:57PM
(#8313918)
How does that grant the carriers the right to deny you service that you are paying them to have? The property rights of bars and restaurants in no way overrides your contract.
If the bars don't like mobile phones they can ban them, or even (assuming it's legal) install Faraday cages.
Re:Trying to Hit the Brake on Texting While Driving
by rayiner on Saturday September 13, 2014 @08:29PM
(#8314161)
I believe the suggestion was to allow carriers to disable service at the direction of private property owners.
Re:Trying to Hit the Brake on Texting While Driving
by 3825 on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:55PM
(#8314382)
Property owners do not own the electromagnetic spectrum in their property. I'd go as far as to say that even the carriers do not own the spectrum. They merely rent it (in the US). I'd say they have certain implicit (and explicit) responsibilities when they assumed the spectrum slices.
Did we really go so far as to welcome intrusion where someone can just ping your phone to get a reply with our location? I for one was very concerned when BART shut down cellular connectivity in order to cover up its incompetence.
Re:Trying to Hit the Brake on Texting While Driving
by Retric on Saturday September 13, 2014 @11:16PM
(#8314411)
You can easily block all cellphones on private property without broadcasting crap. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faraday_cage
Texting while driving is a public safety hazard, and that's pretty unambiguous. From where do you derive the right to control what I do in a bar or restauraunt?