News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sotomayor Issues Challenge to a Century of Corporate Law by sp332 on Friday September 18, 2009 @06:43PM (#831325)
OK, I've talked with some people and it seems to me that the issue here is primarily ownership of money. One of the major advantages to having a corporation is separate bank accounts. Basically, the corporation, as a "person," can own money and property that is legally separated from its owners'. This means, among other things, that if a corporation is sued, the owners don't lose money out of their own bank accounts. But it also means that they can;t give that money to a campaign in their own name. If they want to use that money, it has to be given in the name of the corporation. If corporations lose their right to free speech, campaigns could never be given any of the money in corporations' bank accounts.
Re:Sotomayor Issues Challenge to a Century of Corporate Law by btilly on Friday September 18, 2009 @07:34PM (#831399)
Lose their right to free speech? What right to free speech? Centuries of jurisprudence have never recognized a right to free speech for corporations. Corporations stand to GAIN a right here, not lose one.

Here is my biased view of the issue. If corporations gain the right to unlimited direct political advertising, then they will have a much more powerful lobbying option than any they have already. This will give incumbent corporate powers increased influence.

It is the nature of incumbents to try to maintain their dominant position by fair means or foul. Therefore we'll see companies asking the government to erect more powerful barriers to competition. These barriers will often be bad for startups and innovation.

Obvious examples of barriers are expanded patent and copyright laws. However that is just the start. Suppose that the oil industry decided that the right president pursuing the right foreign policy would improve their profit margin by 5%. If they had invested 1% of their 2008 profits into the last election, that would have been more than both presidential campaigns spent together. Is this really how we want US policy decided?