News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sotomayor Issues Challenge to a Century of Corporate Law by bokonist on Friday September 18, 2009 @04:33PM (#831137)
In my humble opinion, everyone is wrong in this article - Sotomayor, Butler, Marshall.

A corporation should not be considered a person in and of itself. A corporation is a contractual agreement between people over the ownership of property. This was the original understanding of a corporation, until the courts started creating this weird, and wrong, personhood doctrine. A corporation should not have rights - a corporation is a contract - the idea of a contract having rights is non-nonsensical.

But Sotomayor is also wrong. The people running the corporation, and the people owning the property do have rights. Just as Arthur Sulzberger has first amendment right to hire people to speak for him, shareholders of a corporation have a first amendment right to hire people to speak for them. The government has no right to restrict the freedom of speech of employees or shareholders of a corporation.

Re:Sotomayor Issues Challenge to a Century of Corporate Law by anigbrowl on Friday September 18, 2009 @05:58PM (#831272)
Sotomayor has not suggested such rights don't exist - how you drew that conclusion, I cannot understand - and the WSJ's summary of proceedings seems misleading to me.

The transcript is at http://www.supremecourtus.gov/oral_arguments/argument_transc... and I urge people to read it. The relevant portion is as follows:

JUSTICE SOTOMAYOR: Going back to the question of stare decisis, the one thing that is very interesting about this area of law for the last 100 years is the active involvement of both State and Federal legislatures in trying to find that balance between the interest of protecting in their views how the electoral process should proceed and the interests of the First Amendment.

And so my question to you is, once we say they can't, except on the basis of a compelling government interest narrowly tailored, are we cutting off or would we be cutting off that future democratic process? Because what you are suggesting is that the courts who created corporations as persons, gave birth to corporations as persons, and there could be an argument made that that was the Court's error to start with, not Austin or McConnell, but the fact that the Court imbued a creature of State law with human characteristics.

But we can go back to the very basics that way, but wouldn't we be doing some more harm than good by a broad ruling in a case that doesn't involve more business corporations and actually doesn't even involve the traditional nonprofit organization? It involves an advocacy corporation that has a very particular interest.

In other words, she is asking the attorney for Citizen's united if he is aware that the basis of his argument for invalidating Austin McConnell (in which a court ruled that Congress had the right to balance electoral and first amendment considerations) would create the basis for a challenge to corporate personhood itself, by making the right of corporate speech pendant on past court decisions which assumed the validity of corporate personhood without ever having formally established it.

Your point about employees and shareholders enjoying free speech qua individuals makes ethical sense, but have you considered that treating the corporation as proxy for the rights of its human owners or agents would conflict with the idea of corporate severability, the legal framework which protects shareholders from direct legal liability for wrongdoing carried out on behalf of a corporation by its officers?

sorry for the long-windedness :-/

Re:Sotomayor Issues Challenge to a Century of Corporate Law by bokonist on Friday September 18, 2009 @06:29PM (#831307)
I haven't read the full Sotomayor transcript, but this overall quote exists in the context of a debate about whether corporations are allowed political free speech, and I have some strong guesses about which side Sotomayor is on.

Your point about employees and shareholders enjoying free speech qua individuals makes ethical sense, but have you considered that treating the corporation as proxy for the rights of its human owners or agents would conflict with the idea of corporate severability, the legal framework which protects shareholders from direct legal liability for wrongdoing carried out on behalf of a corporation by its officers?

Corporate severability is bogus. Shareholders should be held to the same level of criminal liability as anyone else who knowingly profits from criminal acts. In practice, this would be rare, as shareholders in public companies would not knowingly profit from criminal actions, because if the actions were publicly known, they would be immediately stopped.

Re:Sotomayor Issues Challenge to a Century of Corporate Law by anigbrowl on Friday September 18, 2009 @06:52PM (#831343)
Your guesses are no more than preconceptions, and asserting that she's wrong on the basis of what you imagine her views to be is a poor standard for evaluating anyone.

Your argument for why 'corporate severability is bogus' is mistaken, I believe, but first I must correct myself - 'severability' was not the right word to use, and refers to the validity of a contract if one of its terms is violated. What we are actually discussing is the idea of limited liability - I apologize for the mistake.

Anyway, I guess what you're saying that that the issue of shareholders' limited liability is bogus because they can't be profiting from criminal behavior they don't know about, and when such criminal behavior is discovered it is stopped so there is no profit.

I am unpersuaded. This is like saying that if I am arrested immediately after robbing a bank, I should not be penalized because I haven't had an opportunity to spend any of the money yet and therefore derived no benefit from its theft. Surely, when a company is found guilty of some abuse (eg Pfizer's recent $2.5bn fine), haven't shareholders already enjoyed the profits in the form of dividends? OK, so after such a fine there won't be any more fat dividends for a while, but this is of no consequence to the shareholder who has already sold his holdings I'm afraid I see the doctrine of unlimited corporate rights but totally limited liability as a clear case of moral hazard.

Re:Sotomayor Issues Challenge to a Century of Corporate Law by bokonist on Friday September 18, 2009 @07:19PM (#831379)
Your guesses are no more than preconceptions, and asserting that she's wrong on the basis of what you imagine her views to be is a poor standard for evaluating anyone.

I will bet you $25 that she will not vote in favor of corporations having the right to free speech.

As for the criminal liability issue:

Imagine you loan money to a friend. Your friend tells you he is going to use the loan to buy a bus ticket to a job interview. Your friend promises to pay you back plus 20% in a week. That friend then uses the money to buy a gun, and uses the gun to rob a gas station. He pays you back the money, with interest. You do not know about the crime, but you have profited from criminal actions.

A court would likely not hold you criminally responsible, as long as you had no reason to suspect your friend of using the money to engage in criminal actions. It would probably require you to pay back the money.

If you knew your friend was going to use the money to buy a gun, then you indeed would be criminally liable.

If there was a "wink wink" arrangement (ie, you say to your friend, "here's some money, turn it into more money, but don't break the law, wink, wink"), you could be held criminally responsible.

Figuring out if you knew the intentions of your friend is a judgement call.

Likewise, if I invest in a corporation that I know to be engaging in criminal acts, I should be criminally liable for those actions.

If I invest in a corporation that is secretly engaging in criminal acts, and I have taken reasonable precautions to ensure that my money is not being used for criminal acts, then I should not be criminally liable.

If the company is later convicted for criminal/third party tort charges, and the amount of the fine exceeds the liquidation value of the company, it would make sense to claw back into previously paid dividends, the same way as you confiscate any blood money.

Re:Sotomayor Issues Challenge to a Century of Corporate Law by anigbrowl on Friday September 18, 2009 @07:36PM (#831402)
I will bet you $25 that she will not vote in favor of corporations having the right to free speech.

And maybe you're right, but in this case all she did was point out that the plaintiff's argument would raise such a question and might result in an excessively broad ruling for such a narrow problem. what she did and what we might do in the future are two entirely different things, and you are applying your opinion about the latter to the former with no basis in fact. I know, I'm being pedantic here, but I think you're reading far too much into what she actually said.

Edit: I'm more and more confused about where you think she would be wrong anyway if the did vote this way, since you do don't think corporations should enjoy the status of legal persons. How would a suggestion that corporations don't enjoy constitutional protections infringe on the individual rights of those shareholders?

Presumably, even if DownWithPedro Corp is forbidden from advertising on the eve of the election, I could still write an impassioned screed on the same subject in my own name. to be honest, I think the reason this particular company (in the lawsuit under discussion) exists is not to make a profit but to protect its investors from the financial risks of being sued for libel if they released the film as a group of individuals without the benefit of limited liability.

If the company is later convicted ... make sense to claw back into previously paid dividends ...

I agree with most of what you say. We are not so far apart on the possible implementations. My beef is not with the basics of capitalism per se, but the fact that nowadays at least, arcane corporate structures are all too often employed to diffuse responsibility to the point of meaninglessness. In the Pfizer case I mentioned, one sales manager got 6 months of house arrest plus a $100 fine, which I frankly thought was just as unfair to Pfizer shareholders as to consumers. A few years back I thought Sarbanes-Oxley would lead to meaningful reforms in comporate decision making and risk management, but the events of the last 2 years have proved me woefully mistaken :-/

Re:Sotomayor Issues Challenge to a Century of Corporate Law by bokonist on Saturday September 19, 2009 @12:21AM (#831645)
How would a suggestion that corporations don't enjoy constitutional protections infringe on the individual rights of those shareholders?

Let me rephrase. I believe that corporations are not persons. But I believe that the owners and operators of a corporation have the rights of persons, and they have the Constitutional right to use their corporate funds for political speech. There have been court rulings that oppose this view, and I'm guessing that Sotomayor agrees with those rulings (although you are right, she has not said this explicitly, I read the original article too fast and attributed views to her by association, since I know she's generally a left-wing judge.)

Presumably, even if DownWithPedro Corp is forbidden from advertising on the eve of the election, I could still write an impassioned screed on the same subject in my own name.

If the first amendment means anything it protects the right to pay someone to speak for you, to organize as a group to speech, to organize as a group to fund the printing of pamphlets, etc. Freedom of speech is not limited to me as individual yelling off of a soapbox. It protects my right to organize with others to print newspapers, make videos, promote videos, etc. If I'm going to organize with others, I'll often need to setup a contract to guide the organization - ie a corporate charter. Court rulings that limit the political speech of people in corporations are essentially banning one particular form of organization from speaking, and allowing others (NYTimes and Harvard Corporation get free speech, Exxon Mobil does not). Freedom of speech does not mean freedom of speech for organizations that Congress likes. It means freedom for everyone.

to be honest, I think the reason this particular company (in the lawsuit under discussion) exists is not to make a profit but to protect its investors from the financial risks of being sued for libel if they released the film as a group of individuals without the benefit of limited liability.

Legally, I am pretty sure libel would not protect against libel committed by the management or shareholders.

In the Pfizer case I mentioned, one sales manager got 6 months of house arrest plus a $100 fine, which I frankly thought was just as unfair to Pfizer shareholders as to consumers.

I don't know a whole lot about the Pfizer case. But it doesn't seem like the crime was fraud in the common law sense. Rather they failed to comply with FDA administrative procedures. At least that's my impression of the case ( http://www.overcomingbias.com/2009/09/for-med-free-speech.ht... ), correct me if I'm wrong. Six months house arrest does not seem lenient for an essentially administrative violation. I don't think that represents the sales manager getting special treatment because of limited liability protections.

Re:Sotomayor Issues Challenge to a Century of Corporate Law by billswift on Saturday September 19, 2009 @05:10AM (#831806)
I understood that "limited liability" refers only to the financial liability of shareholders being limited to what they have invested in the corporation, their not being personally liable for any debts of the corporation, in other words. "Limited liability" does NOT protect shareholders, management, or anyone else involved from actually criminal actions they may participate in.
Re:Sotomayor Issues Challenge to a Century of Corporate Law by asdfqwersdf on Friday September 18, 2009 @05:48PM (#831256)
The idea that a corporation should be reduced to a contractual agreement strikes me as problematic.

Since corporations necessarily have contracts with other entities and a contract as an entity can't be a party to another contract, then your corporation would have to somehow specify a process for employees to hold contracts in proxy.

Also, a corporation that's just a contract between individuals can't provide any protection from lawsuits by people who aren't employees or shareholders.

Certainly there's a place for the kind of construct you're talking about, but it seems to be fundamentally incompatible with anything remotely similar to the way business is structured today.

Re:Sotomayor Issues Challenge to a Century of Corporate Law by bokonist on Friday September 18, 2009 @06:23PM (#831299)
Since corporations necessarily have contracts with other entities and a contract as an entity can't be a party to another contract, then your corporation would have to somehow specify a process for employees to hold contracts in proxy.

That's exactly what a corporate charter is. It's the shareholders delegating the management and contracts associated with a piece of property to a process determined by the corporate charter.

Also, a corporation that's just a contract between individuals can't provide any protection from lawsuits by people who aren't employees or shareholders.

The contract can protect from lawsuits by creditors. When a creditor loans to a limited liability company, the creditor knows that he only has recourse to the funds pledged to the corporation. He can not claw back into the shareholders personal funds. Again, it's a matter of voluntary contracts. If the creditor wants that right, he can explicitly demand that the shareholders pledge their own assets as part of the terms of the contract. ( in fact, that's exactly what banks do when lending to very small businesses).

But an LLC designation should not protect from criminal liability. Shareholders should be held to the normal standards of criminal culpability for the actions of the management. A shareholder who knowingly profits from the management committing criminal acts should be held to the same level of guilt as anyone who knowingly profits from criminal acts.

Re:Sotomayor Issues Challenge to a Century of Corporate Law by misuba on Friday September 18, 2009 @06:01PM (#831275)
Corporations as they're structured today may not be contract-like, but they certainly aren't person-like either. I hope a high court or two finds the cojones to admit this and stop trying to do legal code by analogy.
Re:Sotomayor Issues Challenge to a Century of Corporate Law by alain94040 on Friday September 18, 2009 @07:39PM (#831404)
a corporation is a contract

You are not completely correct here, because the corporation itself can enter into contracts with other people (and corporations).

I know the distinction first-hand because when we invented the license behind FairSoftware (http://softwarebillofrights.org/license.html), we had the exact same problem: we are building virtual corporations by using a licensing contract among participants. It's great, but it doesn't create an independent "person". As you said, it's just a contract between people.

Regular corporations are given special treatment by allowing them in turn to do special things. So they are more than a contract.