News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Evidence Points To Conscious 'Metacognition' In Some Nonh... by fnid on Friday September 18, 2009 @12:50PM (#830607)
You said, "Bear in mind"... I chuckled.

But seriously, I think there is a range of cognitive ability. Some animals and perhaps fish or reptiles, living or dead, or birds even, are smarter than others, this is probably true, or at least appears to be true from observation.

However, the big problem to me is that people think somehow humans are distinct and unique and above aaall other life forms. That consciousness begins and ends in homo sapiens.

But, like you alluded to, even within humans, there is a vast range of conscious capabilities.

Re:Evidence Points To Conscious 'Metacognition' In Some Nonh... by giardini on Friday September 18, 2009 @01:59PM (#830751)
fnid says: "the big problem to me is that people think somehow humans are distinct and unique {and _above_ all other life forms). That consciousness begins and ends in homo sapiens."

But except for the part I bracketed, the above is pretty much true. There is little evidence of self-awareness in other animals and certainly nothing like what humans display. Along with that, our language ability is unique (Sure I know about signing apes, dolphins, African parrots, et al, wherein minimal language abilities are present).

No doubt that animals have emotions. But consciousness? No. Animals other than man live in the "here and now". Other than following genetically-programmed patterns, they neither plan for the future nor reminisce about the past as we do. And that is just fine: that's all they apparently need.

Some unique situation (I have no idea what ) must have occurred in man's history for the ability to think outside of the "here and now" to develop.

About the bracketed part: I would omit it because I don't think that there is any design where man has any inherently "higher" role/purpose/goal than other animals.

Re:Evidence Points To Conscious 'Metacognition' In Some Nonh... by TrevorJ on Friday September 18, 2009 @02:32PM (#830827)
The language examples you gave deal with communicating with us. Animals have been shown to communicate with each other as well, and we don't yet know how complex those communications may be.

Also, apes do exhibit evidence of a concept of 'self'.

Re:Evidence Points To Conscious 'Metacognition' In Some Nonh... by giardini on Saturday September 26, 2009 @12:21PM (#845644)
Animal communications is limited to survival calls(warning cries), mating and social signals(which include status signals).

Ape communication is very much "here and now", especially the signing apes: "Mary want banana, Mary want banana, banana, banana, give Mary banana..." etc.

Apes do have some sense of self, but it is far from human consciousness.

Re:Evidence Points To Conscious 'Metacognition' In Some Nonh... by TrevorJ on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @05:07PM (#853691)
I would disagree regarding the great apes. You are correct, it may be far from Human. We are in agreement there, however great apes have shown evidence of planning, remorse and anger that goes beyond the here and now.
Re:Evidence Points To Conscious 'Metacognition' In Some Nonh... by qqqqq5 on Friday September 18, 2009 @03:52PM (#831048)
What about the chimp who would gather rocks when the zoo was closed to throw at visitors the next day?

http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/science/article5877764...

Re:Evidence Points To Conscious 'Metacognition' In Some Nonh... by giardini on Saturday September 26, 2009 @12:27PM (#845653)
Is that any different from the crocodile who waits quietly by the riverbank until the gazelles come to drink?

Chimps also will hunt in packs and use spear-like tools.

But neither behavior resembles human consciousness. A person as bright as that chimp would at best be in an institution.

Re:Evidence Points To Conscious 'Metacognition' In Some Nonh... by scott_s on Friday September 18, 2009 @03:23PM (#830956)
The article describes an experiment where dolphins demonstrate a measure of self-awareness. In happens in the form that they demonstrate hesitancy in decisions, which implies knowing that their decision may be wrong.
Re:Evidence Points To Conscious 'Metacognition' In Some Nonh... by a-priori on Friday September 18, 2009 @02:19PM (#830801)
Animals other than man live in the "here and now".

That's a very strong claim. Care to back it up, especially in light of the linked article?

Re:Evidence Points To Conscious 'Metacognition' In Some Nonh... by giardini on Saturday September 26, 2009 @12:32PM (#845658)
The experiment interprets the dolphin's hesitation as "metacognition". But most animals will hesitate and equivocate their action under the right circumstances. Certainly all mammals.

Give your dog a treat. When he takes it, immediately pop him on the nose. Offer another treat. If he takes it, pop him harder on the nose. Keep going until he hesitates. Voila, "metacognition"! (Unless you have a pit bull, in which case you may have difficulty reaching the metacognitive level).

And the second question: does this equation hold:

"metacognition" = "human consciousness".

Re:Evidence Points To Conscious 'Metacognition' In Some Nonh... by a-priori on Friday September 18, 2009 @01:21PM (#830664)
Haha, I didn't even see that pun. Good eye :)

Let me clarify though: while I don't think humans are much different from the other mammals, I think it's a big stretch to lump us in with fish and reptiles. The key is the neocortex, which is unique to mammals.

(Birds are another story that I don't know much about. I'm tempted to think that through parallel evolution at least some species have developed a similar faculty without a neocortex.)

More important than variations between people are variations within one person over time. I remember cases when, as a child, I didn't understand what was going on around me. Maybe I did at the time, but I realize now that I didn't. I was still conscious and aware of course, but had a much simpler model of the world that I was working with.

I imagine that's what it would be like if you could see what's going on in another mammal's brain -- very similar processes going on, with a simpler model of their environment.

Re:Evidence Points To Conscious 'Metacognition' In Some Nonh... by gloob on Friday September 18, 2009 @01:34PM (#830692)
But, like you alluded to, even within humans, there is a vast range of conscious capabilities.

I'm not entirely certain that that is what was being alluded to (although feel free to correct me if I'm wildly off base). Some branches of philosophy (especially philosophy of mind, especially philosophical idealism, especially solipsism) that are internally consistent but raise the question of whether consciousnesses other than one's own exist at all.

A fairly common question, for instance, when talking about strong AI is: How can we tell if it's conscious? Since we lack any real sort of objective metric for such a thing, there are two plausible answers: 1) We ask it, or 2) We follow our gut and make a guess. Both of these answers have fairly obvious problems with them. All of those problems apply just strongly when we're dealing with the idea of animal consciousness as well, or even with the idea of anything other than oneself being conscious.